I liked that scene. :grumpy

There was a thread about this topic already.

^ You're right... and not only one... there are like 3 or 4 threads about this already!! O_O;;

Sorry about that... :(

again? anyway, itwould a bit over broad for me, even though the scene itself looked nice, and it might not flow toghter at all.

Besides it makes "the making of..." video more interesting.

all those threads, and this is the first i saw about it? 0_o;;

but yeah, i liked that scene, how the leaves were blowing and all, but it probably doesn't fit with the pv that well. all that spinning around her kinda made me dizzy too, haha!

blah I stopped reading...okay I think they should make an acoustic version like they did to dearest but this time have her singing in the swing the whole time instead of standing...Must be aching eh?

Ayumi Hamasaki
CAROLS ~ Acoustic Version

I guess you could say that the Hammond b-3 mix kinda was an acoustic version. It would have been really cool if they used it somehow with the swing footage, especially if they slowed the film down somewhat to match the mood of the song!

that scene was really nice honestly
it was a shame to cut it

Anyone have pictures of the swing scene?

CAROLS was so painfully dull it would have been better to have included that scene just to add a bit of variety to the damn video...

But at least it did included in the making-offs..... we still be able to catch a glimpse out of it..... It's not just windy, but poor ayu has to endure the chill too!

i think it's a waste not to put that scene, it's so beautiful, and what's wrong with ayu's hair being messed up? i think it's natural, and the camera-effects in the scene is so great, i mean, it's a very good scene, too bad it wasn't included, but THANK GOD it was inserted in the Making of CAROLS scene...

I want pictures/video. Can anyone take screenshots or upload this for those who didn't see?

i like it a lot too!

too bad they didn't include it

i actually find it very amazing that they build that big swing and rolling axis camera...i never knew u can film like that before

That might be the reason why they cut it. It's like oh we found gold! Look at this great material for "making of,,," footage. It gave you something out of the ordinary for a change, didn't it?

they removed maybe they think it'll make ppl go dizzy @_@
but i love that scene ...the contrast between black(stage) and white(swing)
it was a great idea

Love Appears I can upload it for you

EDIT: http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=28497

Did anybody noticed that when the camera was almost upside-down, we can see one person on the right side of the screen (somebody's legs) :] Hehe

It's an okay scene, it's pretty but I like the video just fine without it. But if they did do a CAROLS accustic (sp) they should do it all on a swing.