Overrated - M (though I do love it ^^;; )
Underrated - HONEY

Over- M
Under- Key -Eternal Tie Ver.-

overrated- dearest, no way to say,

underrated - End of The World <--relli kool song!, Humming 7/4, Daybreak

Does no one know how to read?

Qt Mashi and Akurei, I can't believe you two. Well actually, I can. Nonetheless, how could you not follow directions when they were in bold, red caps? I mean c'mon.

Overrated: Dearest
Underrated:INSPIRE

owell, it's hard to not break any rules :P

Overrated: Dearest (Am I the only person who finds this song really, truly boring? Errgh.)
Underrated: Key -eternal tie ver.- (One of my favorite songs. Amazing lyrics. So pretty. ;_; )

I completely agree!

overrated: Dearest
underated: SCAR

overrated: SEASONS
underrated: HONEY

M, really a nice song for newbie Ayu-lover, at least this is the first song attracted me :) So I think it worth overrating

Overrated: evolution, Boys & Girls, Trauma, walking proud, CAROLS, About You, and flower garden
Underrated: definitely For My Dear... at the first place :( gave almost ignored
TO BE, monochrome, too late, End roll, vogue, ever free, Far away, Key, P.S II, NEVER EVER, HOPE or PAIN, Replace and many many nice songs are often underrated

Overrated: Trauma. well, that's for the Japanese... they love this song to death, yet there are other cutesy fast songs better than this which can have hand gestures to perform with. Fly High and Audience for instance.
If I have to pick an overrated song among the forum people, (Trauma isn't as popular here as in Japan :p) I would have to go with M. It's a nice song, but it's just too overrated. It ain't the best ayu song I know

Underrated: I'm having a hard time deciding between Naturally and monochrome, but in the end, I chose

Scar

Hahaha It's not even in my original choices :p I was looking at my ayu mp3s finding any song which I may be forgetting, and I came across this song. I always loved this song and it's never mentioned much at all. So sad that it's sooo underrated. So much so that it's rarely mentioned at this forum :(

WAY friggin overrated: Greatful days (>,<)
WAY friggin underrated: Heartplace

can't believe the total disregard for the one song only portion of the first post.. come on seriously guys.

Overrated: INSPIRE
underrated: About You (one of my favorites)

I was debating between INSPIRE and Dearest for Overrated.... I like about you a lot too.

over: SEASONS
under: Far away (AMAZING song)

Overrated: Evolution
Underrated: Scar

Overrated:Ourselves
Underrated:Who...

Damn, Who... is one of her best ballad songs and it´s kind of underrated =(

Over: Trauma
Under: RAINBOW

overrated: dearest
underrated: monochrome (and maybe ever free)