i choose YUI

ERIKA

YUI! I don't know....I loved her even before Taiyou no Uta...

Drama is obviously better. Erika acts better.

song wise both tie.

and YUI just have the Kaoru Amane look. so i voted for YUI

It's weird. I listened to YUI awhile back and I didn't care for her. I've just recently been introduced to ERIKA by a friend, and I liked her music...but after watching most of those two PVs, I have to say that YUI's was much much better. I really like that song, and I think I'm gonna go download it!

YUI is better, music-wise. ERIKA strikes me as a decent actress with a decent voice, but nothing about her stands out. It helps that "Good-bye days" is one of my favorite YUI songs, though.

Kaoru Amane is a fictional character that composes her own songs, sings on street, plays guitar, shy and cute = YUI