I'm almost 100% sure that EnergizE is lip synced. (But there seems to be a reason, what with the insane performance, so whatever.) AUDIENCE seems very live to me, considering not only does it sound a little different (which it doesn't have to be very different, since it's an easy song), but you can hear her take an awkward breath in the beginning, hah. rollin' definitely has to be live, I think... And Sparkle, now that I hear the verses, definitely sounds live, too. I guess the chorus just has a lot of backtrack in it. (Which I actually prefer, because songs like that can sound pretty boring sometimes without a lot of back-up vocals of some sort.)

That seems to be a trend here, whenever she is doing something good, there is always something "bad" in the back.

^ No, she has had good vocal performances for sure but I don't say all of them are lip synched or back tracked. :) Even in these news clips I said Evolution sounds very good but I do not suspect that one of being lip synched. There is just certain evidence from what we have seen and heard from Sparkle that points to it not being completely live and therefore I'm not going to say "oh she sounded so great in Sparkle" or something like that.

Haha xD Me, too, much of PCDL to me seemed playback, but was sung too bad to actually be playback xD But I guess I know the reason: It's very likely that she decided to sing something playback AFTER her accident, so she wasn't able to record tracks that are as good as her usual playbacktracks, makes sense, doesn't it?

Note to everybody: Please don't kill me xD I didn't name any specific songs and it's only a guess, but it seems really possible to me, because Ayu always wants to give the best possible performance

This happens to me all the time as well, just surprised my mother yesterday when watching TV, because I noticed a playback after around a second and she didn't notice at all...for Ayu it's much harder than for many others, because of her new recordings and her more-or-less realistic mouth movements, she does it so much better than most artists.
But I'd prefer not to notice it at all as well, especially when I'm not sure about it it kills me a little inside, because I can't enjoy the performance as much as when I'm sure it's live, but I want to enjoy it.

Nah, that makes sense (puts away samurai sword) LOL ;)

I didn't say it's impossible and I said it myself that I am pretty sure the back track was being used during the choruses. I usually don't say that she sounded "great" just that I like the way it sounds and to be honest we all know that she had some songs lip synced that sounded terrible ^^

That's what I thought as well, she is partially deaf, but not totally tone deaf ^_^ Don't worry I won't hurt you :P

I personally think that the playback talk should stop...it's wishful thinking though.

As I and others have said, it's better to be blissfully unaware and be able to enjoy a concert, and then come to your own conclusions, but it just gets irritating when members of this forum continuously try to persuade everyone else to believe something is playback.

Like, I think it was, TH said, we're never going to know whether or not a song is playback unless Ayu messes up with the lip movements. Other than that, no matter how strongly your intuition says, it's purely speculation.

I don't see what's to gain by pointing out playback and then trying to get everyone else to agree. :P

[/my involvement]

All sounds live to me (EnergizE, AUDIENCE, rollin', Sparkle) thou :) In EnergizE esp. when she sings : Put you hands up toGETHER, keep your hands up toGETHER, let me sing foEVER......
she doesn't dance as tough as Namie and Kuu, why can't she sing (sounds) well U_U. And you guys still complain just like Eason did.

I thought I could find some other news footage and pics or clips but all I read is still the same stuffs: LIP SYNC. Like seriously guys...pages and pages talking about this.

oh well
nuff said. I hope the DVD is out soon and I can enjoy it.

As long as ayu doesn't go britney on us, I'm fine if ayu lip synches a few songs in a concert...with majority of the songs live. I really have no interest to find out or to know which song she lip synches. When I watch her concerts, I don't focus on her mouth movements or try to hear if there's a difference compared to previous concert performances and studio tracks. To me this is not why I watch her concerts. I watch them for enjoyment.

this :)

hahahaha..
the playback thing comes back again..
and we gotta go back to the thread at Ayu's Chat room, to discuss about the playback thing again..

It's really more that people get over defensive about the idea. Or maybe its better to say that people try to prove that she didn't, just as much if not more so than people saying that she did. ;) I should be able to say "I don't think Sparkle has such great vocals as everyone thinks because it doesn't sound live to me", without it having to go on for pages. :) Plenty of people said that Energize was playback over and over again yet for some reason that didn't start anything.

Neither do I. I try to just sit and enjoy the concert, but I just notice it naturally. Some people are just more attuned to things like this it seems, like noidea said.

I dont think Vogue was lipsynced at all... but its matters of opinion, right?~

I don't think I've seen anybody here prove she didn't lipsync. All I see is some trying to prove her lipsyncing and others pleading for it to stop. :laugh

Madonna doesn't playback THAT much, actually. In the Confessions tour it seems only Sorry is playbacked.

Anyways, back to Ayu...

100% sure playback:
EnergizE
AUDIENCE
In The Corner

(I saw her concert twice.)

Sorry...

Oh Ayu... I don't like her cutesy voice, neither while singing nor speaking (although speaking is much, much worse, cause singing is part of a performance after all).
I listended to the live recordings truhappiness posted and I was literally dying trough the first words of rollin'. XD
It sounds horrible, but somehow it is fascinating to me at the same time this time, it's weird. XD
If rollin' is really such a funny and strange performance I'll love it, cause I love weird things (and the cutesy voice fits then). :laugh
And by the way rollin' is with Sparkle my fav song from NEXT LEVEL.

In The Corner, too? oh no :(
and are you sure Sparkle wasn't playback?

well, In The Corner already was suspicious in PCDL, we might get something by comparing the vocal tracks, IF AT09 performance is playback(and IF PCDL is playback), she will most likely use that recording again

Wow when I see Ayu live, I wish in my heart I wouldn't be like some of you guys. Like out of all the things you can say about the concert, only playback/lypsynch gets to mind in your posts? I find that sad if a few songs of her summed up her whole concert... At least if playback affected you that much, isn't there anything positive to talk about her concert too? Like you guys did went to see her...

^ Most people on here unfortunatly were not able to actually see the concert yet and talking about the setlist or the costumes at this point just isnt interesting anymore

And post about playback are definitly better than these "I want the DVD to come out" "It's gonna be so amazing!!!!!!" oneliners