Maybe I'm just deranged or something but I thought the doll falling part was hilarious. I actually laughed out loud. :laugh

It was a good PV, I enjoyed it.

I jumped when I heard the noise of thunder then I was like OMG when the tear fell form her eye slowly then she started to cry that was awesome, I like how her PV's tell a story sometimes, this PV is very nice. ^_^

Wooooooooooooooo absolutely LOVED IT

Best PV from GUILTY until that day^^, I love it, even if it reminds me a little "rainy day" PV... The parallel and contrat between the Xmas and happy atmosphere of the real life and that, sad and desesperate, of the marionets is incredible!!

MOREOVER WE ARE IN FRANCE^^ It makes me loving the PV a bit more (I know, French people are chauvinistic^^)

Yaa~ I notice this too, though there are so many mistakes, ne? xD

^I dont know french, but the big van was indeed french :P

I was hoping for something a little more different as well.

I can't really judge the PV right now though--only watched it once. It was confusing to me, yeah, and I didn't think it was SUPER great, but then again, I only watched it once.

I almost cried when Ayu cried though...

I really loved it a lot! One of my favourite Ayu PVs in a long time I think, it sort of reminds me of Momentum but with better metaphors and a little more thought behind it.

I admit, it almost made me cry. So sad really. I can really connect with the lyrics in this song and the PV in a way.. so yeah.

I like how before when she's on the bench she's like kind of happy, then when the puppet falls and breaks its like... tears and more, expressed, sadness.

Awesome *satisfied smile*

odd, i thought her crying was less realistic than in the past. Well, I guess it's just less dramatic and thus more believable, but I still prefer her hanabi ~episode II~ "WATCH ME CRYiNG" moment :P

i haven't saw the pv yet :c

Awww, it was sad. I really liked the idea of using the puppets to act out Ayu's emotions, and the cinematography was great.

It moved a bit too slowly for my tastes....like did we really need so many scenes of Ayu sitting and doing nothing, and Ayu the puppet walking away from / standing behind the guy puppet?

I thought her crying looked kinda dumb, but whatev.

This isn't a criticism or anything, but did anyone else think Ayu's face looked sort of different? It looked rounder and chubbier....I don't mean fat, but she looked more childish.

Final comment: I would not get into that taxi with that creepy driver. o_o

Yeah Hazuki there are a lot of mistake^^
First, the steering wheel is on the right, it only exists in the United Kingdom and Hong Kong (I don't sure about this...)

Then, the marionet theater is in english... Weird...

And there are two errors on the shops' names

http://img442.imageshack.us/img442/8...0356739am0.jpg

http://img240.imageshack.us/img240/1...0359192ec6.jpg

And finally zoomzoom yeah the van is french, a Citroen one... But it's really and older one, from the 60'...

Well, pray for Masashi Muto to direct again. XD [He did Ladies Night and Depend on you]

Strangeness like that only comes from lots and lots of.. stuff. :X

^ Well it does seem that it was set kind of back-in-time-ish =p

Also, i thought it was really sad how no one wanted the 'puppet ayu' from the puppetshow. I felt that was symbolic of her loneliness...

Ahh, so much to say about this PV.. so good.

You know, it's kinda sad that we finally get an Ayu-ish PV [after like, BLUE BIRD, Startin', Born to Be... and etc] and people are like, "Oh, I wanted more than this."

:|

She can't push out alternas all the time. :<

I agree.. I guess people have high expectations, but I think it was great.. I'm proud of her! =]

In any case, I liked t2m, decision, glitter/fated etc... I like seeing variety, but people have their opinions etc so, although saddening, nothing can be done, ne? :)

She really did. Especially in that black dress.

It was a good PV. Not my favorite, but definitely one of her better ones.