Secret is Ayu's worst album, next to NEXT LEVEL. Only songs I liked were It was and momentum.

Black Cherry, omg that album was hawt. IDGAF what anyone says <3 It has JUICY, it automatically wins.

Koda Kumi's album was better, imo.

Ayu's Secret

Secret - Ayumi Hamasaki

Easily Secret.

Black Cherry

I can't stand Secret :no

Black Cherry is one of my favorite j-pop albums of all time. I like Secret, but not as much as Black Cherry!

Had this been Kuu's secret vs. Kuu's BC, secret would have won. :laugh

Secret <3

but Black Cherry is a lovely kuu album <3

Noooooo! Voted for Kuu, but wanted to vote for Ayu... >_<

Secret

浜崎あゆみ / Secret

Black Cherry. It's one of my favorite Japanese albums of all time. Secret was not that great of an album to me.

When I first listened Secret, I thought it would be awful because that's what I heard people say.
Well, Secret was surprisingly good, and I like it so much, it's very good album minus the horrible songs like Beautiful fighters.
Black Cherry doesn't even come close

I'm sure I already commented, but Secret! LOL

You definitely went there!
Secret hands down.
JUICY can't hold up against 14 Ayu songs.

i vote for secret because Im a ayumi fan.
But Black cherry is very very very close.

Ayu's Secret.

Ayumi's Secret of course.
Koda's Black Cherry is my least favourite album from Kumi along with Dejavu and secret. These three albums pale in comparision with other Kumi albums such as Trick, Kingdom or Feel my mind.

Secret.:yes
It has Jewel!:luv2

Secret all the way, well perhaps it's not fair since I don't like Kumi at all, I only like 2 or 3 of her songs, and 2 of them are thanks to FF X-2 and more than like it's due a nostalgic feeling, I don't hate her tho, and it's sad when people attack her to deffend Ayu (and vice versa as well), they both are great artist but personally I could never get to like her music.

"Black Cherry"
"Secret" is not one of my favourite Ayumi albums :(