GUILTY. I found Kingdom disappointing and HEART STATION doesn't have anything I like as much as the standout tracks on GUILTY.

You still gave her the chance though, which is more than I can say for the hardcore Ayu fans. :rolleyes

Hikki is my fave out of the three, but Heart Station was kinda a let down, so was Kingdom (the ero stuff was better imo). (I still love them both)

But I never get tired of Guilty, it was better than Secret. (Plus I'm lovin' rock at the mo)

Guilty gets my vote.

HEART STATION easily.

GUILTY and Kingdom were HUGE letdowns, really flawed albums, nothing really great on any of those... so sad.

i still prefer GUILTY...solid powerful tracks....Heart Station is also fantastic but lose juz a little bit...Kingdom is alright to me

I'd have to do it this way.

HEART STATION > GUILTY > KINGDOM

KINGDOM was still a good album, but it had the most throw away tracks for me out of these albums, such as Koi no Mahou, Anata ga Shite Kureta Koto and Wonderland. GUILTY was a VERY good album to me, but for the most part, it didn't bring anything new. It was like Ayumi's old work, even if it was done really well.

HEART STATION, to me, is a completely different side of Hikki that I've never seen. It was so calm, melodic, and all around beautiful. It's definitely my favorite album of the three.

GUILTY

HEART STATION

1. GUILTY
2. HEART STATION
3. Kingdom

GUILTY is my fav album out of the 3. I liked all of the songs except for 2 (guilty and glitter) while the other 2 albums I enjoyed less songs. GUILTY contains some of my all time favorites from ayu like marinette, together when...and untitled for her. I also love mirror and the inderlude tracks (well maybe except for rebirth) HEART STATION is also a good album as well. I really like flavor of life ballad version and prisoner of love...this song is so addicting! can't wait for last friends. Kingdom however...the only song I like was black cherry.

Aww lol I am sure a lot of hardcore ayu fans gave her a chance. I gave kuu a chance @_@ I watched A LOT of her PVs but I didn't like any of them (Except Ai no Uta) so YEAH generally I don't like Kuu at all (Except that one song). Maybe the hardcare ayu fans just generally don't like Kuu's music. Its like that for many artists lol not just Kuu. Its just more noticable depending which audience u are talking to.

Hmm I would vote for HS but I still need to hear all of the other two XD! Lol. ._.

I would be so shocked if I found out that my fellow Ayu fans don't like Kuu because of her dirty dancin and that she sell more than Ayu. If that so, then they need to like that go. :rolleyes Kuu has much good music as Ayumi.

@Lacus: Don't wanna sound mean but have you even hear HEART STATION? It seems like you are basing your answer on the two albums you've already heard.

heart station was alright
but guilty ftw!!
coz its got untitled ~for her~
love that song
makes me keep rethinking da happy memories of wen i went to japan ^_^
havn't heard of kingdom though but wif untitled ~for her~
theres no need!
hahas

Guilty

Ayu stays the best... out these three.. so: GUILTY...
Kingdom & HEART STATION where two of my heartfull albums.. but Guilty is more.. expressive.

i love HEART STATION 10/10! GUILTY was absolutely great 9.9/10 hehe and i just don't like kuu so i won't even give a chance on listening to kingdom 0/10

Yay! More HEART STATION fans! I swear, that album just doesn't get as much love as it should.

GUILTY was a great album in my opinion.

Kingdom had better album tracks plus anytime.

HEART STATION had better single tracks minus boku wa kuma plus Prisoner of Love :D

GUILTY
HEART STATION
Kingdom

Actually... some really hardcore ayu fans only hate kuu because she's selling quite a lot, which is no problem AT ALL.. but they already have judged her before even knowing anything about her.. and they will keep that hate while watching her PVs and listening to her music, just to bash every little thing about her. The people who really don't like her music are the ones who calmly say that as you can see, there are more *****y remarks than respect remarks

I'm not much of a Kumi fan myself.. yet, I do think that she's the most girl powerish and daring in a risky way (and I don't mean the sexy image but hanging upside down during performance with risking crashing down, swimming in a water tank for a long few of seconds)

For me it's GUILTY - Kingdom - HEART STATION

GUILTY because I love her rock music... Kingdom because there is A LOT of variety from urban to ballad to pop and HEART STATION last because.... it's her worst work so far and it's just so damn lazy compared to her other work.