Ayumi Hamasaki Sekai

Ayumi Hamasaki Sekai (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/index.php)
-   Artists & Bands (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=66)
-   -   [Utada Hikaru] Songs of Utada Hikaru | the 51st thread (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=120905)

amorphose 3rd December 2014 05:56 PM

Did anyone download the full version of Letters? *bats eyelashes* I think its better than the original!

visionfactory 3rd December 2014 06:08 PM

^I preffer original, Shiina's tracks are always so noisy

Shiina Ringo sings half of the song with an annoying voice then she change to a normal voice which is very similar to Utada's

R_Hikki 3rd December 2014 06:20 PM

Listening to those four previews just now was what I imagine a satanic ritual would be like.

"Letters" was more tolerable than I expected but I have high respects for Utada's original arrangement because it's absolutely one of her best. "Keep Tryin'" was pretty cute, "Sakura Drops" was unreal and "FINAL DISTANCE" was just ok... But overall, this is thoroughly entertaining.

NintendoHTF1242 3rd December 2014 10:09 PM

Honestly, to appreciate Shiina's voice you have to listen to a few songs in her discography. I thought her cover was really emotional and well-done.

Keep Tryin' is cute but it's nothing special.

SAKURA Drops holy shit LMFAO! I actually kind of like it.

I was pretty terrified to hear AI's cover of FINAL DISTANCE cause I stan for that song, but she did work. I like it.

axmish87 3rd December 2014 10:27 PM

SAKURA Drops is my JAM
Sooo catchy i looooove it <3

bluegie 3rd December 2014 11:08 PM

Wow quite a few people hating ringo's voice lol. tbh though that is her signature, high pitch with the twist of "R". Even tho I dun listen to her whole discography, she has really good songs like Honnou, Gibusu, Ringo no Uta, Kabukichou no Joou, etc. I think she did a really good job on letters, as she managed to transform the song to "herself" rather than just covering it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by primavera♥ (Post 3107169)
I also think that final distance is very beautifully arranged and creates this sad mystical world. That is lost in AI's version obviously because it's not hikki anymore. It sounds like a standard r&b ballad or something. And those have to be really outstanding to impress me or just make me want to listen, so I'm not really a fan because nothing about it just clicks with me. It's well done I guess for her though and suits AI best. You can miss me with that though.

I like the Sakura Drops cover....I can vibe with it somehow. Same with Keep Tryin. So I'm excited for the rest.

Yeah, I think AI's FD kinda lost the touch as well. I think her voice is beautiful, but maybe the background story of the song is lost in this cover. Without that the song becomes quite plain.

I just listened to the youtube version SAKURA drops, the opening music was a wow to me lol. The arrangement blends extremely well with Yosui Inoue's old style vocal. I dunno but I'm kinda stuck to old style sometimes, so his version, while may not on par with hikki (yeah I'm biased towards her), is very very good :D.

ahtka-chan 3rd December 2014 11:46 PM

I really loved Letters and SAKURA Drops.

Didn't like AI's cover, her voice is just so... not my cup of tea.

Haven't listened to Keep Tryin' yet, but I'm so happy that First Love didn't make it. I love it's lyrics but I think it's a pretty flat song.

NintendoHTF1242 4th December 2014 12:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bluegie (Post 3107261)
Wow quite a few people hating ringo's voice lol. tbh though that is her signature, high pitch with the twist of "R". Even tho I dun listen to her whole discography, she has really good songs like Honnou, Gibusu, Ringo no Uta, Kabukichou no Joou, etc. I think she did a really good job on letters, as she managed to transform the song to "herself" rather than just covering it.

The first time I actually listened to Shiina was Kalk Samen Kuri no Hana. I did not know what to expect LOL but I really do like her singing style; but there is no denying that her voice isn't for everyone. I do like how you said Letters became more of her song rather than a cover. That's an interesting perspective.

JackieRos 4th December 2014 01:30 AM

I love shiina ringo but I didn't like her rendition of letters.
Letters is my favorite song of Hikki so I think Shiina just ruined it.

Zahara 4th December 2014 05:13 AM

I loved AI's cover. It sounded a bit more like gospel music.

koumori 4th December 2014 06:50 AM

I've liked all the ones posted so far, they have been nice surprises. Looking forward to the rest of the album.

Polyrhythm 4th December 2014 07:02 AM

Oh fuck no....:shakehead

Pieces_of_SEVEN 4th December 2014 04:31 PM

I'm not even sorry...but AI blew hikki's out of the fucking water...

emi♡ 4th December 2014 04:40 PM

I've always admired Shiina Ringo, she's amazing. But I've never been able to listen to her because of her vocals. It's her thing, and it's whatever. I was actually surprised that her vocals weren't as annoying in Letters lol

As I said, these aren't really supposed to just be covers lol They're supposed to be more like personal renditions.


@bluegie: I'm not really a big, big fan of hikki's early arrangements. A lot of them are really basic and dated for me, even if they're somewhat innovative, or were for their time. I just prefer a modern sound.

lol even with Final Distance. I always preferred the piano arrangement to the original. I do think the "sadness" is sort of lost....but I think that makes it interesting.


Also happy First Love isn't here. fml I'm tired of that damn song.

amorphose 4th December 2014 06:20 PM

The range of opinions is baffling me. I can't imagine how varied the reception of Ayu's cover will be. lol

chocopockymaster 4th December 2014 06:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by amorphose (Post 3107343)
The range of opinions is baffling me. I can't imagine how varied the reception of Ayu's cover will be. lol

AHS will probably implode, lmao.

Delicious n Bold 4th December 2014 06:44 PM

It'll implode while utada is STILL MIA. ugh
looking forward to ayu's cover though. i mean if you cover 90s jpop trash then you really have to put in effort to fuck up. and ayu's been on that 90s jpop trash train before so i think her choice is right at home.

amorphose 4th December 2014 07:59 PM

Movin' on without you is not trash! :O lol

Surreal17 4th December 2014 10:52 PM

You guys made me curious about the songs! Especially about Shiina's one!! Where can I download the tracks?

Violently Happy 5th December 2014 01:31 AM

Don't like the previews except for AI's version of FINAL DISTANCE. I love Shiina Ringo's unique voice, but I didn't like the arrangement. Sakura Drops was just O_O Keep Tryin' had very weak airy vocals which made me dislike it. I however do not think AI's cover is better than Utada's. I also find that AI's voice is not for every person as some people might find it to deep. My mom and sister thought she was a guy when they first heard her, and they felt her vocals were a bit harsh.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:12 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.