Sparkle = I love Ayu to be sexy. But in this pv, Ayu is too SEX-yyy!! I don't like Ayu to be like this. I don't mind if she just wear those latex suit(it looks really sexy in Ayu) but, she doesn't have to move the too-sexy thing. But, I still love this pv and the song.

Curtain Call = It's so simple. I like it very much. Ayu wears nothing for her feet?! It's really different! I love it! Nice job Ayu!

conclusion is, I love both pv very much.

Seriously...I thought Sparkle was so damn amazing.
I was glued to watching it.
Her body is just... wow o___o
It's great to see something. She impressed me with that :)

she's bare footed in Curtain call, I think it's very natural, also the way she walks there.. it IS the way she walks, she walks fast.. you can see it a lot on AT's making off..

love her wardrobe there, she looks just perfect..

I thought Curtain Call will turn to sumthing like Green w/ the whole set shown on the Team Ayu's Photo.. everything is good, only she is a bit over express in the first minute, the melody is not that "emotional" ..

Sparkle.. the colors, the 80s, wardrobe are all ok for me, everything looks good.. it's just sum of her moves, well she is hot but really don't want Ayu to be the next kumi.. I'm begging actually, omg just don't..

now that I think of it, there's must be a reason why they show very little of the 80s scene.. only on the opening and the end..

SPARKLE - i still can't believe that ayu manage to make this kind of PV...she looks HOT and FIERCE...i don't know if there is symbolsym in this PV or there just a random thing... and i trully love the last part where they show her 80s appearance again...she looks UBER cute when she said "arigatou gozaimasta"...ITS REALLY CUTE...

Curtain call - i think its a one take PV shoot, i don't understand why the director make her walks that fast too...and the part where her bodyguard give her umbrella is kinda out of place...but i love the color and the song is so touching...and she not using any shoes so she looks so humble and down to earth, and she looks tall in this PV, i mean...without shoes..but she looks tall!!! i give her credit for that

i satisfied with both PV, i think the HQ version will make it looks even better

Sparkle:
I predicted that it was going to suck, and I was right. I was almost scared while watching it! XD Yep, the leather suit part really reminds me of Oops! I Did It again mix with Fergie in Koda's That Ain't Cool PV. She even did similar moves! Anyway. The red suit part was T-R-A-S-H-Y. Do not want. The 80's idol part didn't fit. Do not like. I think it's my first time listening to "Sparkle". Do not like either.

Curtain call:
This really reminds me of Pride. I do like the concept and it had the potential to be a nice cool PV. I like the 1 shot idea, like HEAVEN. Ayu overdid a couple of times though. She's not a really good actress. :/ Anyway, I liked the concept but I though the result wasn't really spectacular.

Is it me or she's getting really bad at lipsynching in her videos? It doesn't seem as natural as before...

^maybe coz its LQ? and ripped from a website...

Curtain call
Its so simple and reminds me of Christina Aguilera's "Voice Within" MV.
But the difference is that there's a dramatic feeling on the background: rain, snow, falling leaves, and a showering fireworks.

Sparkle
Hmmm... I thought it was an another cutesy PV but when the scence changes, WOAH!
A World of Latex! XD

The purple Ayu and the red latex guys around her really creeps me out!

Its a fresh new PV but there's some elements of western-y style like on Britney and Lady Gaga.


I would say that I love Curtain call PV better.:love

She over acted in Curtain Call. The voice didn't match up with her flailing.

Sparkle wasn't all that bad. It was different for her which is always good. I liked how some of the scenes were shot (laying down in the black while the pink satin moves).

I thought her attempts at sexual movement were ill and just unsexy. Her lifting up her leg and looking at her snatch looked more like a "Meet Your Member" rather than "I'm Sexy".

It's not just you. That's been getting worse for about the last year or two.

For those who are disheartened by Ayu's sexy apprearence in Sparkle, bear in mind shes mocking the sexed up side just as much as the 80's side. I dodn't think Ayu will be making another PV like it, at least for awhile. i still can't get over how mch i like it.

I don't really have a problem with her lipsynching in her videos...I mean maybe her lips do that thing frequently but seriously not that big of a a deal.

Sparkle pv reminds me of lady gaga. The wig, glasses and the moves. It just rubs me the wrong way.
Curtain call is as boring as the song. I like NEXT LEVEL PV the best.

Sparkle just screams SEXY the entire time i love it! Curtain call is a very pretty song, But the PV is just to bad quality for me to really enjoy ATM.

I don't get the feeling from the video that it was actually "mocking" though. If that was the intention, I'd like it more and it should be presented more clearly. Overall, I don't have a problem with the outfits or anything, just a few key parts where its like "Ok, that is waaay too much."

yeah agreed :yes it's like Startin'

Well maybe mocking isn't the full intention/right word BUT definitely tongue in cheek and not 100% serious you know? Like Ayumi wouldnt be humping Shuya's (i'm sure it was him haha) leg if she was 100% serious.
Exactly! Startin was Britney and Missy Elliot Sparkle is Lady gaga.

I like both pvs!!

Sparkle is very different and cool. it didnt disappoint me.. I like the different shots of Ayu!! Ayu is so cute at the start being a 80s singer. hahaz

Curtain call is touching.. the pv can be kinda boring but it's simple and Ayu express her emotions as it is. ^_^

curtain call is really...simple. i don't like her hair, but i even though it's simple, i loved the scenery and setting of the whole PV. the song isn't so bad either, but not the best ayu ballad.

sparkle is CRAZY. i was scared at first watch, but now i just find it amazing, lol. i love ayu with long black hair.

Apparently Sparkle is Lady Gaga hits Music Station at 1980s and then come back to 2008.

Does anyone notice ayu owns the chart at the beginning of Sparkle PV?
She owns Music Stations top 5 chart.
LMAO

Sparkle (red outfit,long black hair)
First thing that came to my mind when I saw that:
Angeline Jolie

I like the part in sparkle where it zooms in on her ass. ayu has a nice ass. And yeah, I think it's a bit of a mocking PV, and in any case it's still an awesome PV.