Ayumi Hamasaki Sekai

Ayumi Hamasaki Sekai (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/index.php)
-   Ayu Chat-Room (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Ayumi in SLT = oh, another GaGa copy? (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=99614)

perfectodub 25th March 2010 05:24 AM

GaGa is nothing new...just madonna music couple with Bjork videos

madonna + Bjork = GaGa

SURREAL__RAINBOW 25th March 2010 05:25 AM

URGH Gaga copied ayu:

Lady GAGA ---> bold & delicious gagagaga part
poker face ---> ayu's first single :/




^shouldnt be this way around?? seriously...



if lady gaga wasnt famous right now people would still be comparing ayu to madonna :/


so meh

Foyuki 25th March 2010 05:26 AM

okay
the time I saw it is written director-XXX(also directed Ladies Night.)
I won't consider that too much to TIE UP Lady GaGa.
As GaGa has become a "shocking style icon".this is hard to avoid.
I can just understand in one way
ayu's is not another copy in Sexy little things
But her actresses and actors in her PV is.
This condition resembles Ladies Night.

jbrat2219 25th March 2010 05:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by all.night.raver (Post 2291706)
But this video looks GaGa-ish. Not a bad thing. Just saying. You can't say that it doesn't look GaGa-ish, just a teeny tiny little bit?

Personally as a fan of both, I have to say no. Gaga never crossed my mind at all. I don't think it looks Gaga-ish in the least bit.

Zeke. 25th March 2010 05:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jbrat2219 (Post 2291739)
Personally as a fan of both, I have to say no. Gaga never crossed my mind at all. I don't think it looks Gaga-ish in the least bit.

OMG, I give up :shakehead. Lol.
I wish the situation would have went like this:

AHS Member #1: "Hey this kind of reminds me of GaGa!"
AHS Members: "Yeah, it reminds me too"
AHS Members: "Cool, Ayu is great!"

The end. Lol.

Seeing the preview just brings up GaGa in my head. Not copying. Not stealing. Not plagiarizing. Just reminding.

xLitax 25th March 2010 05:47 AM

^ And we're all entitled to different opinions. :D I honestly, didn't even think of tra-- "GaGa" at all.

Zeke. 25th March 2010 05:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xLitax (Post 2291778)
^ And we're all entitled to different opinions. :D I honestly, didn't even think of tra-- "GaGa" at all.

Yes, I must say I hate when other members go and bash people for having opinions. But to me it seems like the only reason people are saying it isn't GaGa is because they feel it's what they have to say to defend Ayumi. GaGa similarities does not mean Ayu is a terrible person and artist and unoriginal. I think that's what everyone is taking it as and that is not what I'm saying at all.

emi♡ 25th March 2010 05:54 AM

The relationship that Alexander McQueen has with Gaga is bound to circulate when people see other artists using his specific designs in their productions.

It's not rocket science.

I personally thought of him and his collection when I first saw the outfits.

That's my pov since I pay attention to fashion. Other people will see other things, other people will see complete originality.


In any sense, people saying Ayu copied = stupid. People insulting Gaga because they think she's overrated = just as stupid.

chloeM 25th March 2010 06:04 AM

i know comparison will make someone better... but don't create haters~

SURREAL__RAINBOW 25th March 2010 06:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by emiko (Post 2291791)

In any sense, people saying Ayu copied = stupid. People insulting Gaga because they think she's overrated = just as stupid.


:yes


this comment should end this thread for good

AyUta 25th March 2010 06:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by emiko (Post 2291791)
The relationship that Alexander McQueen has with Gaga is bound to circulate when people see other artists using his specific designs in their productions.

It's not rocket science.

I personally thought of him and his collection when I first saw the outfits.

That's my pov since I pay attention to fashion. Other people will see other things, other people will see complete originality.


In any sense, people saying Ayu copied = stupid. People insulting Gaga because they think she's overrated = just as stupid.

Couldn't agree more.

Kingdom 25th March 2010 06:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SURREAL__RAINBOW (Post 2291737)


if lady gaga wasnt famous right now people would still be comparing ayu to madonna :/


so meh

true words

Crystal_Ageha 25th March 2010 06:35 AM

I hate how a few people are saying that GaGa is already bigger than Ayumi. C'mon now, really? This is GaGa's peak, and it's not as big as Ayu's was. Also, do you really think GaGa will still be going strong in another decade? No way.
There's no reason at all for people to be trying to claim she's already more successful.

Kingdom 25th March 2010 06:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Crystal_Ageha (Post 2291838)
I hate how a few people are saying that GaGa is already bigger than Ayumi. C'mon now, really? This is GaGa's peak, and it's not as big as Ayu's was. Also, do you really think GaGa will still be going strong in another decade? No way.
There's no reason at all for people to be trying to claim she's already more successful.

ayumi is not a worldwide sensation and she wasn't at her peak. she is mainly famous throughout asia. lady gaga has touched all over the world and has many worldwide number one hits. that's why people say lady gaga is bigger than ayumi.

perfectodub 25th March 2010 07:07 AM

Lady GaGa is famous worldwide not only because her talent ..is famous becase she belong to the USA music indutry..and USA industry have the money and the power to make any kind of artist (trash or not) famous in a worldwide way, the same with the movies, the same with clothes...etc.

RocknRoll 25th March 2010 07:08 AM

You can say what you want, but that Ayu is using some exact same outfits as GaGa (like the X-factor Bad Romance outfit) is pretty lame IMO. There are so many outfits out there, use some other ones. The red skinny dress thing is amazing, use more original ones like those.

Aditmi Krisnasaki ~II~ 25th March 2010 07:10 AM

oh.. haters.. o.O

but yeah, I said "Oh, Ayu's copying GaGa" but in a very good way, because I love them both and I thought it will be fun if ayu is GaGa's fan~ :yes

but then again, maybe it's just the trend, the designer.... whatever~

i think it's just the fashion of 2010~ :thud

FREAKY but AWESOME! :heart :luv2

I :heart love it! A LOT..

SKYia 25th March 2010 07:13 AM

I guess people compare them not because the PV itself is weird. To ma Lady GaGa represents costumes that don't fit, oversized, non-standard, plastic, etc, they seem like those first future-like costumes from the 70's. Even though Ayu had some huge dresses they were always exaggerated but in normal standards and looking good. Now I look at Sexy Little Things PV and I don't see Ayu style weird clothes, but typically GaGa style weird clothes: they are too huge, distort the silhouette and go with hairstyle that is looking far too fake (I'm thinking about the black & white clothes with pony tail from the PV).

I don't mind reviving some styles from the past, but I don't like it when two or more stars do it at the same time, why did she have to do it right now when GaGa is already doing it too? Because it's popular, "people like it at the moment, so let's do it" kind of thinking.

ownsarai 25th March 2010 07:21 AM

I don't think Ayu is copying. So what if she happens to use outfits from a few FAMOUS designers? That makes her a copycat? Ayu did weird stuff/make up/clothing/PV's way before GAGA was around. People need to realize this. I've said this before. Obviously people are going to beat this into the freaking ground.

Crystal_Ageha 25th March 2010 07:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by perfectodub (Post 2291867)
Lady GaGa is famous worldwide not only because her talent ..is famous becase she belong to the USA music indutry..and USA industry have the money and the power to make any kind of artist (trash or not) famous in a worldwide way, the same with the movies, the same with clothes...etc.

This. It's only because the U.S. shoves everything they produce in everybody's face. It's hard not to have at least heard her name whenever they try hard as they can to toss it into every media around the world. If GaGa came from Japan, she would have never gotten to be one tenth as popular as she is now, and comparing her to Ayu would be like comparing......Ne-Yo to Michael Jackson. (Random, I know, sorry. >_>)
Japan not only doesn't care about making it outside of the country, but they often even don't want to. Ayumi obviously doesn't care about making it out of Asia, and we know she'd be fine if she was only known in Japan. But despite all that, she has tens, maybe even hundreds, of thousands of Westerners, alone, who know her name. That's a very impressive accomplishment, something that GaGa could only dream of achieving.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 12:56 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.