Winter Love: Not bad

Renai sashin: Plain

Yume no Uta: The melody is great, but vocal part seems wrong somehow
Futari de: Same as Yume no Uta... Erm what's the difference between these 2 songs anyway?

JEWEL: Touching, both melody and vocal sound right

Ranking:
1) JEWEL
2) Yume no Uta
3) Winter Love
4) Renai sashin

jewel LUV it !!!!!

ayu rocks!!!!

Prob a little biased on this site ;)

It was really hard to decide between JEWEL and yume no uta. Both really good songs. I ended up going for ynu just because i was sure it would need the votes.

I like^^


welllll I dunno if that´s just me but Ayu´s voice didn´t convince me this time =(

well.... it difficukt not to chose by the fav. artist, once i think Kumi´s voice is the most powerfull....

I think i have to listen to the instrumentals tracks to judge then....

hey u was supposed to judge the SONG.... lol


just kidding ok =):P

I voted for Winter Love. I love JEWEL, but Winter Love took the cake.

Ranking:
1. Winter Love
2. JEWEL
3. Renai Shashin
4. Yume no Uta

JEWEL!!!! :)

Futari de... next, hehehe.

1. Renai Shashin (love the lyrics and melody)
2. Jewel
3. Winter love
4. Yume no uta (I think it's a bad song.)

Winter Love is so good <3

But it's not a JEWEL <3 Renai Shashin is so good too.. D: D:

Well I don't like any of this ballads very much...
Jewels sounds anyway non-special to me although I actually love every ballad of Ayu^^"

1.JEWEL
2.Renai shashin
4.Two left

Ayumi Hamasaki - JEWEL

JEWEL is THE BEST

1.) JEWEL
2.) WINTER LOVE
3.) Renai Shashin
4.) Yume no uta
-------------------
end of comment

BoA, even that she's my fave but i really like this single!!! Winter Love was just perfect for me. Ai's one was good 2!! Still haven't listened to Ayu's cuz I'm waiting for her album ^^

Kuu's... I totally agree with u. It was not that GOOD, she didn't impressed me either.

:yes

My Ranking:

1) JEWEL
2) Yume no Uta
3) Renai Shashin
4) Winter Love

They were all good, but ultimately I picked Renai Shashin.

all of these songs are good , but to me JEWEL & Renai Sashin stand out as the best.

I think I'm going to go with JEWEL , I like the more dramatic chorus it has over Renai Sashin.

After the new performance of JEWEL on HEY!x3 I must say I stand by my choice.