![]() |
Tell me why from Party Queen = cover song?
It seems that Tell me why is a cover song originally recorded by a Greek artist, Ivi Adamou, a contestant from X Factor.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalokairi_Stin_Kardia This was found from a user on Twitter and posted by Aderianu. Quote:
I wonder if Ayu's credits are going to credit the original producers. I like the Ayu version a lot more. |
Both versions are good, but I'd rather sing to ayu's version :D
|
Idc if it's cover, so it's Memorial address and I love both ver (Ayu and original)
|
this song is fantastic. her voice kind of reminds me of Meisa Kuroki. i can't wait for ayu's full version!
|
|
^ lol...
|
o.O it's one of those songs from PQ that I'm highly expecting... I hope that there's no infringement here... But from listening to the original song, I think it's a really nice song.
|
This is like, the one song I actually can't wait for.
If there's infringement, shame on them, but...I'll still listen to the song and not care lol If they don't give credit, it probably is one of those situations where, the rights to the song are sold in different countries...like TVXQ's Mirotic. But shouldn't we have known of cover songs by now? If it's an official cover. Anyway, it actually makes me want to go listen to that girl. |
I really do like Tell Me Why. From the previews this is on of my favourites. Do I feel sad? No. I just pretend I haven't read this.
|
Quote:
|
There isn't any infringement. Do you think a huge music company like avex even bother with a lawsuit? They have the money, they bought the song. It's not like they're not one of the biggest music companies in Japan :rolleyes
|
Memorial address was a cover?!
|
Quote:
Here's a link to the track since it doesn't seem to have been reuploaded onto MediaFire. MediaFire Ayu has such good taste. |
^ yep, it's a great track, both version are amazing imo
|
Quote:
|
Wow. Great find there. From the original (which I like), I think I can expect a kickass ayu version :yes
|
We still dont know whats going on with it so to brush it off is blah.
I like ayumi's covers and if this is a cover it does not disappoint. |
It might not be a cover. I don't believe it is. Either it's stolen or they just sound similar.
|
Quote:
|
Hm....interesting. Not sure though...
|
Quote:
and sometimes, SM entertainment from Korea does the same thing. like Hot Summer by f(x) but of course, we'll see what's real soon |
Every album someone pulls up a possible "cover" from some where to which turns out once the full song is out not to be the same, you can tell its not the same. And anyways ayu always says if shes doing a cover. X-factor basically is people singing other peoples songs or songs that have been arranged for them to sing. Their nothing more than puppets to there agreements for x factor. There's also always people who say someone famous stole there songs too. Madonna gets it a bit
|
Koda does this a lot with her music too. They buy the rights to the song.
|
Is this supposed to be about the music, or the lyrics? I thought Ayu wrote new lyrics for Memorial Address and just used the same music?
|
^ new lyrics for the song of memorial address and a remixed version of the music (a cover)
we dont have lyrics for tell me why yet so who knows if it is a cover or not... still waiting for all the credits and what not |
when did we know that "Beautiful Day", for example, is a cover song? Or it's not called as cover?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
So is it truly a cover song?
|
Oh my goodness!! I can't believe Ayu will do covers.
|
They changed a bit of the melody, so it's not a complete cover, but so far it sounds quite similar. It's definitely taken from that song, no denying it, the melody, arrangement, mix...all taken more or less from it, though Ayu's version seems darker and less poppy.
BTW: If you change the arrangement and write new lyrics it's still a cover, changing the MELODY is what turns something into a different song entirely(and even then changing one or two notes isn't enough). The reason the (m)u songs are no cover is simply that Ayumi released them before Sweetbox, technically the Sweetbox versions are the cover(which is...quite ironic). Memorial Address IS a cover. |
oh come on. I remember we had that same topic with GREEN being a chinese cover.
|
People act like it being a cover(though, not too sure about that yet, we can't know how much they changed, they definitely have something in common, same chords, same melody except for a short middle part, almost a carbon copy arrangement...) is a bad thing. Some extremely popular, succesful and GOOD songs are covers, a good artist makes a cover that is better than the original and so far it appears like Ayumi is doing that.
If you wanna go to the most extreme definition any song not composed by Ayumi/CREA is a cover. |
Quote:
I watched the music video of Sose Me, it is quite lame..... Quote:
|
i'm loving ayu's preview version so much. hope the full track doesn't disappoint..
|
Well, I now have a new artist to totally check...needed some Greek pop anyway =P
Right now my guess is that this is a composition that was sold to multiple labels around the world (thus not in competing markets.) As someone else said it happens a lot between Europe and Asia. If it was sold at the same time, it's technically not a cover I would think. It's usually only a cover when they buy/get permission to use the composition at a later date. Granted the original song here came out in 2009 and it's now 2012. Assuming Ayu first heard of it and wrote lyrics in 2011, it could technically be a cover unless Avex was sitting on the composition for those years. (Ayu said that she's presented with compositions to choose from, and this could've been one of them.) Either way, so long as it's not outright stolen, who cares =P |
kotora, there is an old, I think, Taiwanese song that sounds similar to GREEN. The chorus part, anyway. The uploader of the video accused Ayumi of plagiarism. It was nonsense. You should check out the video for yourself.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I wonder how this song will be credited in the booklet, will be interesting seeing all these new names considering it's usually the same 3/4. I kind of like the original version more than what we have of Ayu's.... oops :( |
even if it is, the song is so beautiful! :luv2
important is that evething should be done legally, enough scandals for now :) |
from tags composers are : Hanif Sabzevari/Lene Dissing/Marcus Winther-John/Dimitri Sta
|
Quote:
I like the original one more. Ayu version reminds me Last Links. |
I actually like the original version more. But I do like both of them very much. Tell me why is one of my favourites on PQ so. :)
|
I don't want to hear the original song >< it'll definitely spoil nice impression Tell me why left.
|
I like original more too!
|
I've listened to the original on the radio and tv many times in the past and its one of my fav songs. Now I want to listen to Ayu's version a lot!
|
Ah! I liked Ayu's version a lot lot lot more.
|
Both are good, but I like Ayu's version more.
|
Quote:
|
a both version amazing) But I like the cover of Ayumi)
|
I love both songs now, I even made my own mashup of them in audacity just for fun. It's a bit chaotic but the intro with them just singing together is so haunting. Wish they could do a collab live, haha.
|
Quote:
You can find it on Amazon.jp for insane prices. http://www.amazon.co.jp/%E8%9C%98%E8.../dp/B00095L76C |
I love how on the Greek album, it's the absolute standout track, while on Party Queen it's just one of MANY incredible pieces of music! haha
|
Oh my, Ivi Adamou, the original singer of Tell me why, which reminds me so much of a Eurovision Song Contest song, is the 2012 participant for Cyprus at the Eurovision Song Contest!
That's a funny coincidence. :laugh |
Quote:
|
thank you so much. I wanna here the original song too much and now I've got it. but I love Ayu's version ♥ original version is too strong to me :)
|
That's actually pretty cool.
I like both. |
AHH! I DISCOVERED this by chance
looking for more songs of the composer, and youtube video popped out, i was like aahhhhhh I'm much in love with Tell me why. I'm just shocked it was a cover... but anyway... I wondered, how Ayumi got such an amazing song writers? and they're from Greece!? she should start looking around gor new composers to ge this standing out tunes... |
I love both version! But I'm smelling a plagiarism controversy around the corner...
|
Quote:
|
Cool, the controversy made me pay better attentino to the song and now it's one of my new favorites. Good to know they credited the original composers!
|
oh wow, until today I thought "rainy day" was her only cover O_o someone should open a "Ayu covers"-topic with all the originals to listen to.
|
It would only be a cover if she used the lyrics of the original song. Taking and using the melody is not a cover, it's more like an adaptation, and Ayu has done it before.
Johnny Cash's Hurt and Whitney Houston's I Will Always Love You are covers(better than the originals). They just sung the original song and didn't change anything. Now, Seven Days War was a cover that Ayu did. I don't know if she's even done five covers total. Anyone know how many she's done? |
Most taken from Zemus' Ayu Tv Lives thread and this thread: http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=96757
As far as I remember... her recorded covers are these (all were performed live at some time): Happening here - TRF Seven Days War - TM Network teens - TRF Someday my prince will come - Snow White Sotsugyou shashin - Matsutoya Yumi Her live only covers: Change the world - Eric Clapton Haru yo, koi - Matsutoya Yumi White Christmas - Irving Berlin Silent Night (with Gackt) - traditional christmas song Tokyo - Keisuke Kuwata Chako no Kaigan Monogatari - Southern All Stars Itsuka no Merry Christmas - B'Z M (with Masami Hisamoto)- PRINCESS PRINCESS Sons of the Sun - Mach25 Shiroi Koibitotachi (with Chemistry) - Kuwata Keisuke Wow War Tonight - TRF Her duets with other bands and artists singing their music: Ageha Chou - Porno Grafitti A Happy Day - Mach25 Ashita Haru ga Kitara -Takako Matsu Ashita ni Kuchizuke wo - Takako Matsu Amairo no Kami no Otome - Hitomi Shimatani Anna - Yoshihiro Kai Can't Take My Eyes Off You - Mika Kano Crazy Gonna Crazy - TRF Curry Rice no Onna - Sonin Dear My Friend - Every Little Thing DESIRE - Akina Nakamori Furui Nikki - Wada Akiko If... - Da Pump Ikiteru Kototsu de Subarashii - Kuzu Intense Romance - Mitsuhiro Oikawa Kagayaki Nagara - Hideaki Tokunaga Kawaii Ano Musume - Toshisuke Nakamura Kimi ga Irudakede - Tatsuya Ishii KISS ni Utarete Nemuritai - Kouji Kikawa Kiyoshi no Zundokobushi - Kiyoshi Hikawa Koi Hitoyo + Arashi no Sugao - Shizuka Kudou Kore ga Watashi no Ikiru Michi - PUFFY Kowarekake no Radio - Hideaki Tokunaga La La La - Maki Ohguro Lonely Chaplin - Masayuki Suzuki Masquerade - Kiyoharu Nagai Aida - Kiroro Okuru Kotoba - Tetsuya Takeda Olivia wo Kiki Nagara - Anri overnight sensation - TRF Papillon - Hitomi Shimatani Rock'n'Roll Kenchou Shozaichi - MiniMoni Sasoriza no Onna - Kenichi Mikawa Saudaji - Porno Graffitti Rouman hikou - Tatsuya Ishii Shoujo A - Akina Nakamori Uwasa No Sexy Guy - Maki Goto 10 Dollars - SMAP Your Eyes Only - EXILE Super Lover I Need You Tonight - w-inds I LOVE WORLD - dream Survival Dance - TRF Crazy Gonna Grazy - TRF overnight sensation - TRF Her pre fame covers: Heart wa Modoranai ~Get Out Of My life~ - Lady Lily and Yu Hayami Konya Dake Dance Dance Dance - Meiko Nakahara Roppongi Shinjyu - Ann Lewis Heart de Shoubu - Mako Ishino Mizuiro no Koi - Mari Amachi MOON - REBECCA Stranger Tonight - Yoko Oginome JINGI Aishite Moraimasu - Miho Nakayama Hold On Me - Kahoru Kohiruimaki RASPBERRY DREAM - REBECCA The songs she bought the rights and re-worked: Bold & Delicious - Geo of Sweetbox Ladies Night - Geo of Sweetbox In The Corner - Geo of Sweetbox Pride - Geo of Sweetbox Beautiful Day - Geo of Sweetbox rainy day - Geo of Sweetbox Tell me why - Hanif Sabzevari, Lene Dissing, Marcus Winther-John, Dimitris Stassos Anything wrong? Missed any cover? :P |
You missed Memorial Address under the last point I think ;)
|
^It seens like neither the lyrics or the melody were taken from the original song, working more as a "answer song" or "Ayu's take on the same idea" than a reworked song...
|
Oh ok, I never listened to the original song, only read about Memorial Address being a "cover"(which it wouldn't be even with the exact same melody...) many times.
|
Quote:
Thanks. |
^She actually sang with a lot of jpop legends...^^
|
REBECCA covers?! Even if they are prefame days I still gotta check those out, can't believe I haven't seen those
|
The other version is not bad, but I definitely like Tell me why more.
|
| All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:51 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.