![]() |
[2007] Which artists/groups do yu think are overrated?
1. Mariah Carey!!! I really don't understand why she's always number 2 on the best voices in modern music lists! I tried her album The Emancipation of Mimi, and it was like songs from tons of different artists sang by just any other woman. They didn't really seem original to me. And her voice didn't move me at all...
So what about everyone else? What musical acts do yu feel get way more attention than they deserve? *Oh, and for some reason i cant stop thinking that ive seen a thread like this, so if there was one, sorry about making a new one!! |
Akon. I hate his voice and his songs are just ridiculously stupid.
A lot of rappers, too. |
The reason Mariah's so popular is because of what she's consistently done. Her earlier albums showcased a superb vocal ability that she's till known for to this day. However, her voice just isn't quite the same as it used to be, but she's still viewed as a legend for what she once was. I think she deserves it, but I also agree that Mimi was a very blahhh album. I wasn't a fan. I miss the old Mariah.
As for who I think is overrated, I'm not really sure. That's a tough question. I guess maybe Ciara was when her first album came out. I really don't think she's anything special, at all. Quote:
|
^ I actually think Eminem is very talented, and I usually cannot stand rap.
Hmm... I think that HIM is overrated...I built myself up to think that they were great and then when I actually listened to them I was unimpressed... I cannot think of anyone else at the moment but I'm sure that someone else will come to mind. |
ORANGE RANGE.
50 Cent ..:lmfao at pathetic rap music. The Pussycat Dolls / Nicole Scherzinger. Nelly Furtado. SELLOUT i'll have more later :D |
Akon and Beyonce. I don't know why people think they're so great.
|
Quote:
|
Most American singers, lol...
Especially the tweeny boppers... |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Akon beyonce pussicat dolls and A LOT of rapper..and ayaka
|
I hate Eminem, Justin Timberlake & Mariah Carey >.<
|
John Mayer.
|
I can't stand Justin Timberlake.
Or Madonna. I don't think she could hit a note if it were nailed to the wall in front of her. And her lyric writing is really absurd. I can still appreciate her as a pop-icon, but I can't take her seriously as any sort of artist. |
voltron.. watch out..
if Vinylfantasy saw that.. :P |
Quote:
|
Rhianna (sp?). Is it just me, or can she not sing for anything? D:
|
Quote:
|
Timbaland. It's not even like he's the artist on most songs, he's just there.
The other month in an hour on the radio about 5 songs came on that he'd produced and 'sang' on. Fergie! If she has to say in every song that she's not a ho', then she's obviously giving off the wrong impression. Lily Allen and Amy Winehouse - Enough said. Shakira. I was actually one of those who liked her before Laundry Service, and still didn't see that album as a sell out. But she's since dissapointed. A lot. |
Madonna and Justin Timberlake
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
But I SO agree about Timbaland! :eviltongu |
I don't get John Mayer either. His songs are bland to me, his lyrics irk me, and his voice just grates my nerves.
Mai Kuraki. I have never understood how she was so popular. A majority of her songs bore me to tears. I like a few of her songs, don't get me wrong, but if I don't like at least 5% of your songs, there's a problem. =( I don't really listen to a lot of mainstream Western music to comment on the others. |
Quote:
|
Timbaland. Akon. And...hmm, AHA. Paris Hilton.
|
ai otsuka:
Bad vocals, the verses of her songs never matches the chorus, and seriously, I see no talent in being cute and doing cute stuff and drawing cute things when almost 90% of japanese people (a joke, but geez, a lot of people there do that) already do that. When are people going to realize that plasying piano and composing music doesn't equal talent if you can never even match the entire song well? She can put porn and perversions into her videos (CHU-LIP) and people will still praise it as cute, innocent, beautiful, decent material. And the ammount of over-defensive fanboys that will attack you if you even dare say anything about her is scary, watch out they get really violent just because you've criticized her work. I do like many of her songs, though I still think she's overrated nonetheless. |
^WHOA. I couldn't agree more.
|
ok, here goes:
Western Music U2 I think they get too much credit/attention than they'd deserve, most likely because of Bono's humanitarian work. As a band I feel they're overrated. Christina Aguilera her vocals border screaming to me, and her latest album just isn't that good. P.Diddy he needs to rely on other people collaborating to make a hit. Japanese Music Mai Kuraki all her music is really dull and her singing is mediocore |
Quote:
Quote:
|
I agree with U2. Although I like their Joshua Tree album quite a bit... that's about it. No matter what they put out, everyone seems to like it, when, imo, it's pretty bad :no
|
Ai Otsuka - My God Ai, Your ballads suck now.
Fergie - Yeah, the first three singles were good, and then you threw out that crappy ballad. Eww. Justin Timberlake - SexyBack? WTF Kind of title is that? The song's twice as lame. Fall Out Boy - Most Pathetic Attempt at Rock Music Ever The Used - You're first album was great, WTF happened to you guys? Good Charlotte - First Couple of Albums were Great...Good Morning Revival = CRAP. Avril Lavigne - Loved your first two albums, and then I *was* excited for your new album till you had to put out that horrible excuse for a pop song. So I'm not gonna listen to anything but your old stuff, and like three songs off The Best Damn Thing, k? K. Evanescence - Love the new album, but never gonna be as good as you once were. Amy, we all know you hated the singer from Seether for being drunk - we get the picture. Don't have to sing about it in every song. Bolded the ones I couldn't agree with more. |
more to add!
Beyonce - she seems to scream in every song! I would take Michelle and Kelly over her any day! Hinder - omg Hinder...grr they make me so mad...all they are to me are Nickelback rip-offs.. and i agree with Ai Otsuka, U2, and Timbaland. |
Justin Timberlake - music is soooooooooooo corny. makes the hair on the back of my neck rise.
Jay Z - can't rap, can't dance, can't do jack shiz. Beyonce, he is sooooooo replaceable. Maroon 5 - all they sing about is sleeping around and one night stands. and Adam Levine's voice is sooooo annoying... and he's one arrogant, cocky s.o.b. w/ LSS (lead-singer syndrome) ahahahahah. Fergie - horrible spelling-lesson songs. and BOOM! there's the ballad with the corniest lyrics Fall Out Boy - horrible. just horrible. Akon - aaaaaaah, if a man with that voice can make it, anyone can! wtf do u call that? sounds like shiz! Sean Paul - i hate this guy and his music with a passion. Rihanna - sounds like annoying horsefly. she's so h-lla h-lla gay gay gay... Nelly Furtado - she's a horselfy too EDIT: how can i forget! Mariah Carey - lame.a$$.music. ur cellulite a$$ needs to retire. u belong only in the 90's. PSD - nothing original. they are boring. period. |
Quote:
|
ANY rapper. ANY. A.N.Y. nuff said
(a few rapping in songs aren't that bad, like haikara and kuu...but just rapping the whole song and calling that 'singing'...that's just a hhuge disgrace...) |
I hate Snoop Dogg. I don't see how anyone can really like him. I just HATE his lyrics and people think they're the best....yeah right!
|
Avril Lavigne have you seen her new remix of Girlfriend?!
as if the song wasn't bad enough, she has to remix it with that pretty pony~pretty pony~pretty pony~pretty pony~ 'Lil' Mama'! you know.. "my lipgloss is poppin', my lipgloss is kewl". ugh! That Nelly Furtado, she totally changed her image and music just to go mainstream. and it's also Timbaland's fault too! none of her pop / folk stuff was charting so she called all these lame rappers to work on "Loose" so she could get in the hip hop / r&b genre! but congrats to her! :rolleyes two #1's and and 5x plantinum album.. selloutttt |
Quote:
I'd love it if Timbaland would stop "producing" tomorrow. I've heard what he's got to offer and now that he has gotten so arrogant, he can leave. I've never liked Akon and I don't understand why people like him. Dani California is a cool song and Desecration Smile is okay, but all the other RHCP singles from Stadium Arcadium are so annoying. |
Justin Timberlake. I think Justin's music is simply terrible and has no creativity; there's just no variety in his songs. The lyrics don't make up for them with their dullness, and his voice makes his songs even more grating to listen to. I don't see what's so great about him. :shrug
John Mayer. I can see why people may like him, but I find his songs particularly irksome because of the lyrics. His voice sounds distorted as well. Overall, his music is mediocre to me. |
Quote:
As for two I just remembered, The Red Hot Chili Peppers, which I thought of from criminal's post. I've never liked them, and their stuff from Stadium Arcadium may even be crappier. I just can't stand Anthony whatever's voice. And I may get flamed for this, but I could care less. I think that the most overrated band of all time would without a doubt have to be The Beatles. I'm sorry, but I am not a fan of any of the member's voices. While I may certainly agree with many of their political beliefs, that hardly means I care for their music. I can't describe it; I just find it to be really irritating. Oh, and Elvis. I can't stand him... |
Quote:
|
Quote:
and yes! Hinder! that guys voice sounds like he's got a loogy in his throat that he really needs to spit out. not only that, their music is just plain dull and repeated. it's so.... bleh..... |
Quote:
haha kiddin'.. well I agree with all of you but I still have most of those ppls Songs in my iPod. I mean they're OK to listen to.. except AKON I can't stand him & his "Nobody wanna see us together..." :headache LOL but You guys Can't deny u know the lyrics to must of his songs.. It's inevitable. But he's corny YES!!:yes Oh Well :o Snoop Dogg & Fergie tought me how to Spell xDD |
Quote:
Totally agree there. I don't get why people think they're the greatest band ever. Which just reminds me of all the mini wannabe Beatles bands... x__x |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=tastey Worst use of rhyme since Pinks sushi/cutie (To clarify, I'm not saying Pinks overrated :)) |
Quote:
And no, i'mm not a The Beatles freak. I only own one CD with some of their best songs and they aren't really my most favorite band. |
Evanescence
Justin Timberlake Beyonce |
Morning Musume, H!P, KAT-TUN, or any Johnny's & Tsunku's boys & girlsband are totally overrated.
This is what happened when looks are more important then music. |
Quote:
Thanks for that link... it's true she can't Spell... or that guy that wrote the song anywayz... or maybe they do it just to be cool & they're aware it's misspelled? xD:tipsy |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
ugh any of the crap that's in the UK charts these days ..... and most Rap music - it's pure crap ¬_¬ except for Missy Elliott :love
|
Beyonce
Mariah Carey Jay-Z Rihanna Daddy Yankee Pussycat Dolls Diddy Ludacris Britney Spears Justin Timberlake Fergie Kylie Minogue edited: 50 Cent(Face it he fell off after the |
*cough cough* mariah is a bit underrated :P thats my opinion. she is a legend after all.
TEOM was soo good OMG. but E-MC2 was kinda better, but it didnt sell alot T__T and stop hating on mariah >:O obviously, disney stars like miley cyrus and jona brothers are madly overrated. |
Quote:
|
I completely disagree (personally) with those who said Beatles, U2 and Madonna... Without artists/bands like them, music and pop/rock culture wouldn't be the same
Most others are just overnight sensations or this year's trendy act, I mean, Rihanna for example couldn't ever enter the history of music the same way Madonna did |
Akon
Madonna Johnnys Hello Project PCD 50 Cent AKB40 or something crap Quote:
|
Madonna
Britney Spears Beyonce Miley Cyrus/Hannah Montana Katy Perry Lady GaGa Chris Brown Kanye West ohh almost forgot RIHANNA. i HATE her. she's so disgusting. like she literally makes me want to throw up at times. that's never happened with an artist for me :S |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Akon, Miley, Jonas Brothers, Mariah, Kanye, Fall Out Boy...
there are more, but I can't think of them / don't feel like making a huge list :P |
Britney Spears
Jonas Brothers Miley Cyrus/Hannah Montana |
COLDPLAY.
I don't understand what's so great about them, I like only two or three songs. |
Britney Spears
Madonna |
Any of that overproduced pop crap, to be quite honest.
That includes anything from Highschool Musical or what-have-you. Oh, and Chris Brown. But that still falls into the former former category. |
Anything Disney puts out.
Ugh, it's like, Just-Shoot-Me-Now-Music. Miley, Jonas Brothers, High School Musical. damn. Katy Perry to me is a bit...her music is like looped hell. omg. Rhianna a bit too...her music isnt THAT great damn. And a few indie bands out there that all sound the same. And a few "rock" bands too that also...sound all the same. |
most groups from hello project. lol
madonna and omg when scarlet johannsen or w/e her name is began to sing, everyone went crazy over it. she sounds so bad imo :( |
Johnny's Artists. XD
|
madonna
girls aloud ai otsuka Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Rihanna
Chris Brown Christina Aguleria Beyonce Lady Gaga Justin Timberlake Britney Spears Leona Lewis Evanessance Will.I.am Pink |
Quote:
|
Yeah, Scarlett's album was atrocious. I don't care if she "went indie" or not, it was just a terrible album. Paris' was much better in my opinion.
|
Quote:
|
Britney Spears
Lindsey Lohan Madonna Pink Michael Jackson Hillary Duff |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I find western pop culture overall overrated.
|
i think a lot of rock groups are overrated.
nickleback needs to crawl into a whole and die. they can take acdc with them too. i also think leona lewis is not all she's hyped up to be. i think she does have a great voice, with impressive range and all that. but i just HATE the way she sings. its just too much. and yeah, most of the pop people mentioned are overrated too. rihanna cant sing, but has a good image and some catchy tunes. justin timberlake bores me to tears. madonna is kind of annoying at times, but i like how her albums are very thorough and solid. coldplay is soooo self indulgent. ~_~ just go away and sing to yourself already. we wont miss you. |
in the moment beyonce.
but last year was definately rihanna lol. i can think of huge number of overrated artists, im too lazy lol. |
Asia:
Any boybands any girl bands also Koda Kumi = can't believe someone said she sings as good as Mariah and most of her music bores me to death (I like Butterfly and Taboo a lot... and Cutie Honey too... but it's a cover and I knew the song long before) Mika Nakashima = she looks like someone with cancer... her singing have no emotion and she is a terrible singing live (but you can finally feel the emotion when she feels pain trying to reach the high notes) Aiko Western: Rihanna = Can't sing, can't dance, low charisma... why is she famous at all? Kate Perry = Can't sing, can't dance, low charisma... why is she famous at all?² Hilary Duff = Can't sing, can't dance, low charisma... why is she famous at all?³ Christina Aguilera = Yeah, she is an amazing singer... but her music is so.... meh... Mariah Carrey = Don't know... maybe I just don't like her personality (and her music) And I agree that Madonna, U2, Michael Jackson, The Beatles, etc aren't very overrated cause they influenced almost all pop acts we have today at some level... Even if I don't like The Beatles.... |
I've been thinking for a while that...omg all I hear on the radio these days in Rhianna...
I totally missed her becoming so popular. But I think her voice is unique...so that's why they chose to market her. But anyway...at the thread at TN, I recently expressed that I felt Namie Amuro was overrated. I LOVE LOVE LOVE her new stuff. But how anyone can enjoy her stuff pre-STYLE...is beyond me. And she was HUGE... so I guess music was just that different back then...and I'm just not into it or something... |
I never understand how people can say "This list of singers cant sing" ... its always strange to me lol ~! I mean like maybe you don't like their voice or something but they're a singer for a reason right? I dunno just my opinion XD even I say some singers cant sing sometimes out of impulse but i guess in the end I know that they can outsing me anyday : P lol! (of course excluding certain people who use money to get where they are)
overrated .. I'd have to say: Koda Kumi: I don't see anything special about her or her music Rihanna: All of her singles from Good Girl Gone Bad sound the same to me and yet they all did well Miley Cyrus: Nothing special, infact I really dislike her voice and I think she's ugly... XD Akon: Another singer who's voice and songs I find annoying 50 Cent : I dislike his rap, and his personality (list of other rappers that fall under the same category because their raps are all the same) Maki Goto : I just felt that MM made her seem so much better than she is Simple Plan : I dislike their songs maybe that was due to an influence from my friend and her choice of "emo" songs lol Justin Timberlake : I still don't like sexyback... and the more songs i hear from him the more similar they seem to get XD Thats all I can remember for now XD |
Quote:
Most of pop singers aren't amazing vocalists and don't have great voices... their voices don't have good range (like... their high and low notes aren't very high and very low compared to their mid-notes) and don't have much potence (they can't sing "loud") but even so, can use it good enough for their own songs... Ayu, Hikki, Namie, Madonna, Kylie, Gwen, etc. aren't stunning singers... But they learned how to take good use of their voices, so, even if they are not amazing vocalists, they are medium or good ones... (like... 3 of 5 stars :P). Rihanna, Avril, Kate Perry, Mika, Koda, Ai Otsuka, Britney... they all aren't very good (0 to 2 stars :B), but even so, they can improve a lot if they take some effort on it (Avril's singing is really better now than it used to be... Koda is improving with time too... Ayumi was terrible back in her 1998-2002 era) Some amazing vocalists would be... Alan, Ayaka, Ayaka Hirahara, Shimatani, Christina, Beyonce, Celine, Mariah, Kate Hudson... even if I don't like their music or voices (Christina and Mariah, don't like their voices at all), I can't say they are bad singers... Cause they nearly aways are amazing vocalists By the way... Being a good vocalist is not only about singing in a beautiful way... If the singer keeps singing without any coaching, he/she can damage his/her voice for good... Ayu lost her voice past year because of this at AT08, remember? ^^ |
Quote:
Ayu is actually another example of why I think its an opinion. You say she's better than ai otsuka and koda kumi, but she damaged her voice from improper singing, while the other two are fine. Sure she has more years on them, but like her lives now can sometimes be atrocious while namie, koda kumi, and ai are fine. I just included namie to prove that years doesn't mean ur voice should die. But like aiko is another example anyways. She's been in the industry as long as ayu but her vocals are fine! If you think a singer has good vocals, thats your opinion, and if you think another singer has bad vocals thats fine. lol : ) I'm just stating my opinion that its more about how people percieve it. Of course there are people with bad vocals but I think most singers have good vocals and thats why they're singing. We just don't appreciate some vocalists because we don't like the sound of their voice. |
Hmm among non Asian people I think alan is way too over-rated, and Japanese Visual Kei bands, I can't seem to get a good idea why many girls (out side of Asia of course) love them that much, they dress like women with extremely bad taste and their music is quite generic and stupid, well I guess the fact that most of their fans are younger than 15 explains a lot xD
As for Japan, I think that ayaka is way too over-rated, she has an amazing voice, her songs are good at times, but her music is mostly plain and boring pop. EXILE - way too generic for me to handle, their songs contain way too many random english lines which barely make sense. KAT-TUN - sure they do have a few catchy songs, but I don't really see why people like them, they don't even look good. aiko - I have nothing against her, but she is among people I find boring. I personally find Hikaru over-rated as well sometimes, but since I might get in trouble for saying why, I'll leave it at that. As for the non Asian music scene, I have no comment xD |
Quote:
Utada's Kremlin Dusk at Utada United for example... I know a lot of people that think that performace is amazing... But if you ever show that to any singer teacher or vocal coach, I'm 100% sure he/she will ask you if she really is a singer :B If I say that singing good is having beautiful vocals, I'm lying, beautiful or ugly are a matter of opinion, you can like koda or ai vocals even if they aren't good taking their Vocal technique in consideration , Utada is my favorite music artist in the world and she is far from sounding perfect =) |
Quote:
As for bands/singers I think are overrated... Britney Spears Miley Cyrus (why is she popular again?) The Jonas Brothers (just...no.) Akon (he doesn't even SING, it's a computerized voice over his own voice...) I've started to think Linkin Park is a bit overrated, too. I love their older stuff, but they pretty much went mainstream and I can't stand that. I don't know much about Japanese music besides the bands I listen to myself, so I can't really comment on that aspect of it. |
Quote:
|
^Ah well, I respect that others don't like them and all, I just wish people would realize that not just teenage girls like them. I became a fan of VK when Dir en grey was still visual, so I'm used to the old-school aspect of VK. I also like the eroguro kei bands like MUCC, Merry and cali≠gari. :)
|
Quote:
|
I believe that music (....not the music just for sheer enjoyment <3 cuz that's nice.) is worth it if either the singer has an amazing voice, there are just captivating lyrics (especially if the singer writes the songs), or if the actual music is just so creative an out of the ordinary that you can't hepl but be amazed.
everyone else......I think those people are overrated. Hannah Montana for instance, she has an okay voice but...it's just okay (I personally like it but....her range sucks. It's like she sings the same 4 notes all the time), people are bending over backwards just to buy a lunchbox with her face on it at Target(r)....that's ridiculous |
Mr. Children, ARASHI, KAT-TUN, Coldplay, P!nk, Katy Perry, Kylie Minogue, Linkin Park, Madonna, Muse, Placebo, Sam Sparro, Wonder Girls (I like some of their songs but they sound HORRIBLE live), Ken Hirai, Miyavi
|
^ Just curious, but why do you find Muse overrated? And Ken?
|
Muse = I listened to their BHAR album and the only track I liked was "Supermassive Black Hole".. I don't know why but I don't find their music that special. Personal opinion kay?
Ken Hirai = I find his songs sound all the same.. they're all bland ballads (with exceptions like POP STAR, Kimi wa Su.te.ki,...) and I don't like his voice |
Obviously it's your opinion, that's why I asked you kay? Although judging based on one album is a bit unfair, just like it would be unfair for someone to judge Ayu based on one album I would think.
|
I think The Jonas Brothers are way overrated. =/
Their fangirls go crazy for them...and none of their songs are even good. XD I would understand if they had a one-hit wonder, but I don't think they have... Also, McFly don't do anything for me. XD |
| All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:25 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.