Ayumi Hamasaki Sekai

Ayumi Hamasaki Sekai (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/index.php)
-   Asian Music Chat (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Koda Kumi vs. Misono (http://www.ahsforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=80933)

mimika 8th October 2008 11:57 PM

Koda Kumi vs. Misono
 
I am wondering..they are sisters and they actually looked similar..especially in the past before Kuu's style got more and more developed....have you ever compared them? Why is Kuu so popular and Misono not even as much? Misono was more popular than Kuu at one point...but than her popularity went downhill and Kuu started going up like crazy....

any thoughts??

stepho_chan 9th October 2008 12:45 AM

i unfortunately think that since she left her group and went solo....shes kinda started sucking....shes only had like....3 or 4 singles that i personally liked (misono i mean) VS, Kojin Jugyo, Zasetsu Chiten and Pochi are the ones i like. of course shes good at her poppy stuff....i also think that her vocals (as far as ballads go) are really lacking....i dont think she has the right voice for ballads at ALL....

But what i was going to say is that...unfortunately i think people think shes riding Kuu's coattails in a way...when i think of them i think of Hilary and Hailey Duff, only opposite....weird comparison. That and I honestly think Kuu is far more diverse and her vocals are awesome, nice deep and jazzy...i cant really say for certain why she doesnt do as well...but i'd imagine her sisters crazy publicity also has something to do with it...

Im sorry im rambling and i make no sense.

love in music 9th October 2008 12:50 AM

misono has a horrible squeaky voice. the music she releases is terrible

kirei_ayumi 9th October 2008 12:50 AM

Despite the fact they are sisters, I'm thinking that it deals with their genre of music. to me, I understand that kuu came up real quick and misono just kinda stayed at the same level and then popularity is another big factor...

I've heard some misono's music and it is crap, seriously and she's had wierd cover shots of her albums, especially the most recent one, where's she nakey.

Beauty4123 9th October 2008 12:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thataintcool (Post 1659046)
misono has a horrible squeaky voice. the music she releases is terrible

with VS being the ONLY exception. :P

Luv ~Venus~ 9th October 2008 01:00 AM

^....and Zasetsu Chiten. :yes

IMO, both Kuu and misono are great artist. I tend to like Kuu more because her style of music is what I enjoy listening to. Misono isn't diverse with her music and the last time I look Rock isn't a huge thing in Japan that much anymore (with the exception artists whose been around for a long time now). I must admit that I only like a hand full of misono's music compared to Kuu. Also, misono has horrible fashion sense. No one would really want to look like her or wear the type of clothes she wears. Fashion was a key thing to Kuu's success as an artist as well as style. People like the fact that Kuu brought something new to Jpop. Misono just needs to re-establish herself and her music and maybe one day, her music will be likeable to the Japanese public again. :)

Twinkle ! 9th October 2008 01:15 AM

let's go to past kuu she was never have any popularity but she work hard and she feel so sad but she keep up and try to sing ballad and pop and r&b she keep work hard and finally she found the popularity but maybe misono when she left her group she lost her popularity evreybody left thier group they lost popularity only beyonce didn't
and maybe they think misono find the popularity from her sister i think she should keep up and work hard

but really i don't have anythink to say only that

it's so rearly to find woman artist who sucsess in japan

bulmasman 9th October 2008 02:14 AM

Once she left DAT i pretty much lost all interest in misono... and once Kuu started releasing a billion singles/compilations/albums i entirely lost interest in here too... so for me it's pretty much lose lose on either side lol.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Twinkle ! (Post 1659073)
it's so rearly to find woman artist who sucsess in japan

This i disagree with... you have Ayumi, Utada, Kuu, YUI, Otsuka Ai (though not AS big now, she's still a success), Nakajima Miyuki, Noriko Sakai, Nakamori Akina, Seiko Matsuda... realy there's quite a list to go back on.

Strawberryfieldsforever 9th October 2008 02:17 AM

I love Koda. I don't even listen to misono and she seems so non-existent to me. I don't even know she exist until Koda.

LacusClyne 9th October 2008 12:07 PM

To me, misono have not improve, her music still stay the same, but kuu had work hard and try different genre and work up her popularity.

misono needs to find the true her

xLuna&1LOVE 9th October 2008 12:08 PM

^ Indeed.. so also for me Koda Kumi

Zeke. 9th October 2008 04:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Beauty4123 (Post 1659049)
with VS being the ONLY exception. :P

:yes

CoriKaru 9th October 2008 06:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LacusClyne (Post 1659599)
To me, misono have not improve, her music still stay the same, but kuu had work hard and try different genre and work up her popularity.

misono needs to find the true her

Does Misono wear clothes?

If so then problem solved. Just take 'em off.

Worked for Kumi Koda.

:yes

ImpactBreaker 9th October 2008 07:42 PM

kuu is better, because she focus on different styles that never wears her image off, and that keeps us interested. misono got stuck into a randomness oblivion of nonsense :shrug

elepop 9th October 2008 08:03 PM

Kumi and Misono are alike and so different in the same time. They both got really strong vocals that are both strangely annoying and irritating at times. That doesn't stop me from liking both of them though.

I don't listen to day after tomorrow so I can't judge Misono's past works. But I can say that she has improved a whole lot since her 1st solo album (I don't even listen to it much anymore....). Her second solo album is one of my favorite of 2008. Before, she was really squeaky and too poppy. Now she's heading towards rock and it sounds incredible.

As for Koda, her previous music was better in my opinion. At her peak, her music quality got worse and worse. But I think she is heading back to quality with TABOO.

Ayumiko 9th October 2008 08:50 PM

kumi went to the right direction while Misono went to the wrong one. I can't stand Misono's voice. Her high pitch is worse than early ayu. I listened to Misono's new song...the one with her wearing a wedding dress...I actually like the song but her voice ruined it and I cannot listen to it again. Also Kumi is physically more appealing and so is her work. Misono...her chopped off naked body album covers still bugs me...:dead2

ville 10th October 2008 05:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by thataintcool (Post 1659046)
misono has a horrible squeaky voice. the music she releases is terrible

so true :yes

Lee^ChaN 10th October 2008 06:42 PM

of course Kuu, i don't like misono's voice
i heard some of her live performance while still with DAT
and mostly she sang out of tunes..
and it's awful..

Kobayashiwoof 11th October 2008 04:14 AM

misono was quite good untill her 3rd single imo. But yeah, Kumi is heaps better in terms of music and as an entertainer.

stepho_chan 13th October 2008 02:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CoriKaru (Post 1659932)
Does Misono wear clothes?

If so then problem solved. Just take 'em off.

Worked for Kumi Koda.

:yes

Oh but she has and it didnt work XD *see hot time cover* (i think....im not sure but there is one where shes topless.)

Huaka 13th October 2008 07:57 PM

Misono has such screechy vocals sometimes, but a few of her songs have been really good. I think that's probably why she's not doing as well as her sister.

Princess Sohee 13th October 2008 08:03 PM

MISONO ROX!

CoriKaru 14th October 2008 05:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stepho_chan (Post 1664100)
Oh but she has and it didnt work XD *see hot time cover* (i think....im not sure but there is one where shes topless.)

Oh well that's a shame. That's like the last resort to go to. If that didn't work, I'm afraid only talent will. :yes

Chandrachan 18th October 2008 03:32 PM

Koda totally changed her style of music and appearance

While Misono kinda stuck with the DAT style and she put on a amount of weight while Kuu lost it

Richieooxx 20th October 2008 07:58 PM

i like Misono better. She's just to freakin' cute

Squeeky voice? clickkkkk

RikkuK 20th October 2008 08:08 PM

is this a joke?
Kumi is waaaay better

Halla 20th October 2008 08:22 PM

DAT had a couple of good songs, mainly "Faraway" & "Starry Heavens". I just don't think her solo music is as good as DAT's, eventho it's sorta similar from the little I've heard.

Misono has never had much popularity as a solo artist. one contributing issue to her lack of popularity is that she has problems with her image. she has been on a sort of a "celebrity weight loss"-reality tv show, so it's clear that she isn't doing so well. and she's also considered "big" by japanese standards :o

emi♡ 21st October 2008 12:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sunday ♥ (Post 1671796)
i like Misono better. She's just to freakin' cute

Squeeky voice? clickkkkk

interesting....

I wonder how it would be if misono went all tommyheavenly6 style or something.

mimika 21st October 2008 06:14 AM

i feel kinda bad for misono

imagine the stress level you have when your sister is soooooo popular....while you are struggling for your career

sora-kara 21st October 2008 04:59 PM

i like misono.
her first album was painful, but it had a couple of great singles.
her next set of singles were all pretty good, and i was impressed with how the album turned out. i think im gonna go buy that actually....

and the way misono does the whole 'no clothing thing' is more scary than sexy.

kuu certainly has a better image, but shes now into the more typical jpop 'starlet' scene. whereas if misono were to have that type of image all of a sudden, it wouldnt really sit well with her music. id like to see her stick out more rockish stuff. she has a great rock voice (so does kuu, but she can manage the pop stuff no problem too).

having said all that, i do like kuu better.
but thats probably more or less because we have a lot more to go by with her.
i think misono could be a fantastic artist, she just needs to keep up the work. :)

mimika 21st October 2008 09:45 PM

she looks sooooo like kuu in this pic

http://wiki.theppn.org/Image:Ninin_Sankyaku_Promo.jpg

BoBo 27th October 2008 11:50 PM

you only talk about how she sings...
take a look a bit of how she looks :P i like her :D
http://i223.photobucket.com/albums/d...4o/Misono1.jpg
she looks charming ^^
http://i223.photobucket.com/albums/d...yaku_Promo.jpg
and here she looks even better than her sis :P anyway i won't mind being a brother-in-law for either of them :D

v3lun420 28th October 2008 08:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kirei_ayumi (Post 1659047)
Despite the fact they are sisters, I'm thinking that it deals with their genre of music. to me, I understand that kuu came up real quick and misono just kinda stayed at the same level and then popularity is another big factor...

I've heard some misono's music and it is crap, seriously and she's had wierd cover shots of her albums, especially the most recent one, where's she nakey.

Honestly, misono was up quicker than kuu at first. Kuu was struggling when misono was having success with her Band, Day after tomorrow. Until Kuu sung FF X-2's theme then she came up real quick. If only she wasn;t offered that role in FFX-2, she might still struggle until now. And honestly misno wasn't as bad as she is now. I dunno what happened to her voice, probably it is due to her sister popularity now that she feels that she has to catch up or sumthing. it is funny how they changed places so fast just because that one role.

And I don't think genre has anything to do with it. There are some great j-urban singers who, imo, as good as or even better than Kuu but they still struggle until now, some even failed and never came back. it was all thanks to avex and its great marketing power and off course a good booster (head start) like ff x-2. Though I have to admit some artists, even with a good head start still failed miserably.

SURREAL__RAINBOW 6th November 2008 04:43 AM

LOL
i prefer koda

^^

pommy48 6th November 2008 04:48 AM

misono is really cute...but does she look like sifow to someone else? @_@...

hikaricore 6th November 2008 11:47 PM

I personally prefer the music of Koda Kumi.
As for everyone saying how cute misono is...
I think she and her sister look almost the same.
And Koda is NOWHERE near as beautiful as Ayu.

AyumiBest 10th November 2008 07:53 AM

The only songs I liked from Misono were faraway and starry heavens and those songs were like back from when she was still in Day After Tomorrow.

I like Kumi's music better. I can get into her songs unlike Misono's. O.O

Kingdom 10th November 2008 08:04 AM

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VzAmKv3Rxtg

i really dislike misono. imo, she's just flat out gross and has NONE of the personality or talent her sister posesses. i feel bad for her because it has to be hard having really famous relatives while your own fame was shot to hell. and now that she's taking her clothes off for grauvure pictures i can't help but wonder if she's trying to follow in you-know-who's footsteps for popularity.

brand new love 10th November 2008 08:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hikaricore (Post 1692449)
And Koda is NOWHERE near as beautiful as Ayu.

lol how does this have anything to do with kumi vs. misono?

anyway, i like kumi a lot better. her music appeals to me more, i don't think misono can even sing very well. and misono is really trashy imo (yes i am calling someone trashy compared to kumi), the video juicy posted is a good example.

jbrat2219 11th November 2008 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by juicy (Post 1697394)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VzAmKv3Rxtg

i really dislike misono. imo, she's just flat out gross and has NONE of the personality or talent her sister posesses. i feel bad for her because it has to be hard having really famous relatives while your own fame was shot to hell. and now that she's taking her clothes off for grauvure pictures i can't help but wonder if she's trying to follow in you-know-who's footsteps for popularity.

What's going on in that video? What's it about? I'm too lazy to translate the Japanese -_-;;;

mimika 3rd April 2009 07:18 AM

so wat do you think about the latest kuu x misono collaboration?

ren'ai 3rd April 2009 01:29 PM

I don't think misono can sing. She has vocal talent that normal people have - not what popstars should have. If she wants to get any popularity, she needs to train her voice, not worry about her body only.
It ticks me off when people say Kuu only got popular for her sexy image only. What makes her different than others (I don't mean misono) who try the sexed up image and fail is that she can actually sing and is versatile.

mcluva420 5th April 2009 06:38 AM

kuu&misono dont rlly look alike to me ...
i think kuu has a better voice, and shes wayy better looking.
so kuu wins IMO

lovelism 5th April 2009 06:41 AM

Kuu for the win...

relmy 7th April 2009 10:05 PM

I prefere Koda Kumi over misono. I mean, I personally don't think Kuu is very pretty, but neither is misono, so that doesn't bother me~ Neither do I really mind who is the better singer, because on record they pretty much sing the same because I'm tone deaf.

Kuu's songs are so varied and catchy, I never used to like her but she's grown on me! (I still can't listen to some of her ballads though). When I listend to misono though...it was really odd, her music seemed really busy (in a bad way). That really odd chopped up album cover was really disgusting and distasteful too D:

However~ I do think misono's work with day after tomorrow is better than Kuu's work, just because I prefere that kind of music. It's sort of like...misono isn't amazing enough to do some of Kuu's songs, but I don't think Kuu could pull off "starry heavens"~

Polyrhythm 8th April 2009 02:49 AM

Koda Kumi Is beautiful, has a voice to die for, and can dance. Misono looks like a chubby girlband dropout and her voice is horrendous. Sorry =[ She really shouldnt be a singer in the first place.

ストロボ・EdGE 9th April 2009 12:41 AM

I don't know which one is better but I hate that song that they did together// :/ What's it called, "It's all love"? Its annoying as :thud

LaryB 13th April 2009 12:47 AM

LOVE LHAMA SAKI?

hehehehhehehehhehe

chestergringo 25th April 2009 08:47 PM

Certainly Koda Kumi.....Misono is a bad singer

mcluva420 28th April 2009 06:51 AM

i liked "its all love!" misono sounded pretty cuteish :)
i had trouble telling kuu & misono's voices apart in that song though :thud

nemesisyume 28th April 2009 03:01 PM

Misono was good in day after tomorrow :yes
but kuu is much better :D

aqua_crystal 30th April 2009 07:31 AM

misono is a pretty BAD singer. She doesn't even come close to Kuu :no


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:34 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.