Quote:
Originally Posted by ayu_fan929
I'm wondering why we are comparing a Mandarin artist with a Japanese artist now. Can you give me a case where a popular Japanese artist in Taiwan hasn't done well with a BEST album?
|
Easy. BoA's BEST OF SOUL, somehow peaked at #15 on the Japanese Charts in Taiwan. Not doing as well his her studio albums.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ayu_fan929
He actually is doing fine in Taiwan. Name more than Hong Kong based singers that are doing better than him in Taiwan.
|
I'm not sure how Nicholas Tse is doing in Taiwan right now but his last mandarin album was released the same week as Eason's last mandarin album and it debuted higher and stayed longer.
But there are quite a few HK singers who are doing way better than Eason is doing. GIGI leung comes to mind. Keep in mind that i'm basing all these on the rankings on the official Taiwan music chart.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ayu_fan929
If you haven't noticed, I'm fully aware of this. Please don't state the obvious. And if you didn't know being a Cantonese singer does have some effect on how successful you are in Taiwan.
|
I said that "being a Cantonese singer
may not have been the reason why the album didn't do so well."
Quote:
Originally Posted by ayu_fan929
So are you basing that off of one album? Or his entire Mandarin career? Can you find the post where I said that he's more popular than Ayu in Asia according to sales?
|
I'm assuming you weren't paying attention during the whole debate. The whole discussion started because you and Uranus were debating about Ayumi and Eason's popularity in terms of sales. I'm not implying that you said that Ayu's less popular than Eason in Asia. It's that you've been against the facts and have been desperately trying to prove Eason's popularity. The whole point of this discussion that you and URANUS started was about Eason and Ayumi and their popularity.