[Melrose]

^

Only like reaally little parts sound different though. Almost eeeverything else (the way she sings kute and raaaaah) is identical in such a way that is more the same than just singing in the same style. Like, every little breathe is the same. The little things mentioned sound more like a bad quality. I checked out the part after the chorus, and actually I did hear it clearer in one than the other, but that turned out to be mostly just the quality. :S

You have a good point on that the AT07 version has a different beginning though, so it couldn't be copied from that. Which brings me back to my point of how CDL06-07 is the same too. Also compare the bridge. Like you said, that's better to compare. It's EXACTLY the same in AT07, CDL07-08 and CDL06-07. Really high pitched, unlike her live voice. Then compare that to any evolution live version that is definitely live. Like CDL05-06 or Arena Tour 2006. Those sound all different and live, while the AT07 CDL07-08 and CDL06-07 are awkwardly high pitches and just weird sounding, and this can't be said to be just because of the DVD remixing, because I'm checking out the TV version. IMO, she combines live with lip synching.

Also I really dont hear a difference in CDL 0708 / AT07 like you said. I'm going to listen to the wow wow yea yea part on loop now. 1 sec...... No it's definitely the same. Especially the "yieeeeeh" part. Also the "mo mo mo yea yeaaaahe".

CDL06-07 like Solar said does sound more high pitched. I think after that they changed it around a bit into the CDL07-08/AT07 version, but there's definitely SOMETHING going on there. I don't think anyone can claim they're all three live performances, and just happen to sound 95% the same (to me 100%..), while alllll the other evolutions have much more differences between eachother -and- a different sound. :> (Lol for debates!)

If you think about it. Well, if I think about it and assuming I'm right, it is actually logical. [Read: "assuming" I'm right] CDL06-07 and AT07 have big choreography for evolution, and are then lip synched for the sake of having proper vocals. Perhaps she sings a small back vocal somewhere. Then CDL07-08, she has trouble with her voice as heard prominently throughout the concert. They decide to have her lip synch to save energy for other songs. In AT06, however, she has a lot of energy unlike CDL07-08 and no freaky choreography with a high kick, unlike CDL06-07/AT07, so she doesn't lip synch that. CDL05-06 hasn't got such choreography either, and is live. I don't know about the stuff before that, though.