[ayumisrael]

Originally Posted by maikaru

How can YOU be so ignorance???

The whole thing about JEWEL is she is talking about her "treasure," in the last line, she says "My important treasure."
I think it only makes sense for her to be in a winterland of treasures, if she is talking about that.
She is talking about how her treasure made her feel peace and kindness, and she is peacefully and looking kind in the PV.
So I don't know what's the problem of JEWEL...

Did you wanna her to be happy and dancing in Together When...?
How do you know it's a fake? Can you know her real emotions?

Out of all the pv you mention, I think Marionette is the one with least meaning, yet you wanna say its the best? I'm so confused at what kind of pv you like.

don't leave me alone's pv was so good too... except the pants.. ahaha
She was saying how she changes to adapt to things with the change ties,
And how she must always find ways for her to make things feel less hurtful.

I think maybe you gotta re-think about it..
I find a lot of the times Utada Hikaru has really bad pvs.
Much worse than Ayumi. (like Heart Station? Prisoner of Love? ._.)

I just think you should stop making bad talk about someone which a bbs is dedicated to..
You can take your extreme criticisms of her somewhere who hates her.
Because obviously, people her will defend her so much, so no points.

unless you wanna stir trouble~ LOL

oh I love you XDD.
Your posts are always so cute ^-^.

Anyway it's always easy to say that ayu fans are to defending and then write hikki's PVs are the best, I like them better than ayu. Like they defend hikki and it's ok but when people defend ayu it's not.

It's also always easy to find meanings in hikki's PVs and excuse ayu's just for beauty and divaish meanings and not find the true meanings behind them and ayu's crying is always fake while it's a PV and I say - even if she had to fake it, it was for the actual PV who cares if it's fake or not it's for a story/meaningful PV! (and all that because they don't really care for ayu's PVs, but they will care for hikki's even if the whole PV is only about recording a song or sitting in a train which I'm sure they have some meaning in but still not one of her best or interesting PVs.. imo).
Ugh.

I hate those comparisons, they always get the worst of fans (both's fans).
And I also don't like fans of someone who pop somewhere and say "x PVs are better/worst than x" all of a sudden, like our new forum friend did.