[alternarist]

Originally Posted by Ayumi_lover

^are you studying vocal professionally?

No actually.. But i find it very interesting to study the relationship between ayu's movements and her vocals..

Originally Posted by maikaru

if there is any parts off, then it cannot be lipsync, period.
If she used a lipsync track, why wouldnt the entire thing be the same??
It's not logic.
If you play both tracks on top of each other, and it just sounds the same, with a higher volume, then it is exactly the same track.
That's how you tell..

i already pointed out the 2 extremely minor differences between the 2 videos. and these extremely minor diff may just be due to diff sound qualities of the 2 videos.

i actually played both tracks on top of each other and it's exactly the same. But i was just being critical by pointing out 2 very extremely minor differences.

Why dont u do the same thing and play both tracks on top of each other and see if it's the same!! u will be surprised.

Originally Posted by maikaru

Anyways, Marionette is not a hard song to sing at all,

are you saying this on behalf of ayu? or u admit that u are a better singer than ayu?

Originally Posted by maikaru

I am not saying she didnt lipsync, but this method cannot be used effective.

And since u are a female, why dont u try it? really.

Originally Posted by Sasuke Hamasaki

Ayu-sama is never lip sync plain and simple

I always believed this theory until Marionette.

Originally Posted by Yum!Fruit_Salad!

I just tried it now and the movements don't interrupt the breathing much.

that means u didnt jerk hard enough as me.. haha jk!

as i said, this is a very amateur way of finding out if ayu lip syncs. i cant guarantee anything. but from my point of view, ayu did lip sync for this song as i am not convinced that she can sing BOKU without jerky voice.