|
Guys... when I'm saying that her vocals were crappy in MNW and Marionette news reports... It's not something like "oh! it doesn't sound the same", she was using her voice all wrong (and you can ask any vocalist or vocal coach about this), she was messing uo with her breath and she went of key a lot!It was very far from perfect... The TV News Reports are not recorded by the TV News, they are recorded by the concert staff... It's basicly official videos without much edition... And I ask this again: If they used a pre-recorded track in the concert, why would they fix her voice in the DVD? It would be fixed before for the concert, when recording the voice!
And that "recorded flawed vocals to sounds live"... Why would she do that? To sound live isn't to sound flawless, even because she already had some flawless performaces before (Together When... in CDL, it was flawless even in the TV version), every time I saw ayu lip-synching, she was dancing like a monkey with a heart atack (Angel's Song... that performaces at Asian Song Festival, that weren't all pre recorded by the way).
I'm getting a little tired of all this... I'm taking vocal lessons... Not that it make me anyhow better than anyone, but I can notice some small singing mistakes that some people that never took vocal lessons can't (great singers can notice even if the person ate something before singing, I can't do that yet), and I still say that most of the time, Ayu isn't a amazing singer, and most of the time she mess something up in her live performaces, and most of the time, her voice doesn't sound the same in the entire song cause she breath wrongly, she doesn't project her voice the way she should... If this is the kind of pre-recording she is going to have to fake singing... she is stupid... there are a lot of other things she could do to sound "more live" than that without having such dumb mistakes... And Angel's Song was just like that... the pre-recorded voice sounded live, but there weren't any mistakes in her "singing"
If you think she doesn't sing live anymore and that makes her a bad singers and you feel cheated by Ayu, go listen to another singers... There are a lot of jpop artists that sings live a lot (even some that shouldn't never sing live)
|