Quote:
Originally Posted by noidea
OK, playback proof by me: theres one contestant playing the violin while singing(i think he even won?) his mouth and violin are at around the same distance of the microphone, so both should be picked up, in the middle of the song, while hes not singing, he goes around and stands in front of the microphone, but you still hear the violin, its impossible to still hear the violin in the same volume, now some of you will say the violin is playback and the singing live: its not, if the singing was live, you would hear two violins all the time(one live, one playback) because the violin is almost as near as the mouth to the microphone, so if it picks up the singing, it HAS to pick up the violin as well, and if he is in a position where you WOULD NOT hear the singing anymore, you wouldnt hear the violin as well, but you hear the violin
@ MissElin
Youre a very naive person, listen to some ayu playback performances and say that again, they are not near being perfect as well
I read on a german board of an indie band making their first tv performance, they thought they would sing live, but in the tv studio they were told to record a one-take version of their song so they could later sing playback on it
People doubting its playback just because there are false notes are a joke^^
|
I just can't belive it's playback
Those instruments are not probablly real. I mean they don't make any voice when you play them. How you can prove that they are not like that?
and look at this video
at 2:22 his voice is totally same as when he adds something that doesn't belong to that song. And he sings it in a different way in the final performance and in semi-final.
Are you saying that every singer recorded their songs one extra time so if they win they sound happier and add random thank yous there... I mean... come on.
SOME TV live performances are playback like some low budget TV programs when they don't have enough money for real live recording and some of them are not like when Ayu forgot her lyrics. was that playback too?
In ESC there IS real singing. it's a song contest. I mean, singing live can't be THAT hard. ESC has always HUGE budget how they could do something so cheap like that?