Quote:
Originally Posted by Evolution7/4
Thanks goticayu for starting a thread which will turn into nothing but a bashing Nami Tamaki thread.
|
JUST TO MAKE IT CLEAR :
you sure dont know anything about me. you have no rigth to say that .dont talk without knowing. as i said i like both artist and i own almost all her cds .its not because im a fan that a have to praize a 100 percent of the artist that i like . when they do something i like i say it , if they do something that i dislike i will give my opinion about it . that is all.
this thread is not to turn into a nami tamaki bashing . everybody is just giving there opinion. just because people dont have the same opinion as you and criticize te similarity doesnt mean they are bashing .
now i will agree on one point . yes composer are to criticize too but i believe sometimes artist are aware its a cover or a sample . especially if the artist in question is ayumi . she enough well known in japan for people to recognize her voice and her songs ( that they like her or not )
and yes ayu is not always original on her music or costums (cf madonna) but she clearly stated that madonna was her inspiration and give the credit to the artist when its not her song . ( i totally loved her cover haru yo )
crystal ageha i agree with you.
i own most of her discography and that was the only song that "shock me " as a "mmm i know this melody from somewhere else "