[primavera♥]

Imo a good pv doesn't have to have cheesy storylines or some plot or be super interesting to be good. Someitmes pvs like moon are just looking at this gorgeous piece of beautiful art. And DLB may be boring. But it has meaning. And she was able to portray that in a more subtle way. Classier
Ayu may not always be aiming for excitement etc

Anyhow I can't say they've declined. And I'm not a biased old fans who usually sees anything that is older ayu as much better
I got to see most of the pvs 2008-1998 at once
So my opinion:

For my dear
Trust
Depend on you
Appears
Boy & girls
Love ~destiny~
To be
Vogue~far away~seasons
Daybreak
Dearest
Voyage
Carols
Humming 7/4
Pride
Born to be
Blue bird
Glitter
Decision
Next level
Curtain call
Sunrise ~love is all~
Sunset ~love is all~
(And yes I really like some of these. Ayu normally has much better pvs than most people. But they're not like super amazing)

I just don't feel that a lot of these were some awesome masterpieces or something. Ayu still has amazing ones today. Ayu has had amazing ones in the past. There's no point in time where I can just say all her pvs are perfect or generally bad. She has a lot of good pvs imo. I LOVE ayus pvs
I just feel at times her old "classic" ayu image is just somewhat overrated (which is natural for fans to do especially since each like different things). Especially. ASFXX-Duty.
Ayus been A okay to me. Still coming with nice unique to herself pvs. She may always be taking a different direction with them but hey. That all her
I do feel however if u switched the release dates of these pvs some of these new lackluster pvs would be considered great and everyone would be complaining about the old pvs. But I think that's just how things always work.