Quote:
Originally Posted by saigodansu
She already plays piano, thats how she use to write the music to some of her songs as CREA and she has already said the directors came up with the pvs. Leslie created those he directed, same with Muto and Luis.
|
She played enough keyboard(I don't think we ever heard about her actually buying a piano) to write the melodies but stated that she has no knowledge about composition at all - an experienced piano player will come to have quite a bit of knowledge about it. That's a gigantic difference. Everybody can play small melodies on a keyboard, actually playing the whole background instrumental including the chords, submelodies and basses is something you learn for many years. And we have no indication that she can do that.
Also, didn't she say that writing them on a keyboard didn't work for her so she started just humming the melodies to her composers and having them write them down?
And you just brought examples for some directors coming up with them, I asked if ALL the video ideas come from directors and a general statement like "the directors come up with the ideas" doesn't exclude some(exceptions) coming from her. I don't think she has ever made a statement ofthat sort about all of her videos and we know she is incredibly modest when it comes to getting credit for her work. Even if she doesn't come up with the main idea she'll still change everything she doesn't like. No matter how small or big. Example: When the whole staff had to stay longer because she didn't like her hair in GREEN after she had shot some scenes already.