Ayumi Hamasaki Sekai - View Single Post - [Koda Kumi] Continues walking in her 174th thread!
View Single Post
  #346  
Old 17th March 2015, 12:53 AM
Tom Punks's Avatar
Tom Punks Tom Punks is offline
Heartplace Initiate
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Florida
Posts: 3,782
Quote:
Originally Posted by SKYia View Post
People always say crap, they have too much choice in their lives, there's so much music in the world (and you can get it for free easily) they don't feel they are getting something special anymore so they complain when there's something they don't like about it under the pretense that they have right to criticise everything and don't care about neither the artist's nor other fans' feelings.
Actually, we (people in general) really do have the right to criticize pretty much anything we want. And I'm glad we have that right, because music would be some god awful shit if there was no criticism and every pop tart could release whatever feces she/he decided to smear in a CD case every year without financial repercussions. In fact, one of the biggest problems with Japanese pop is that there ISN'T any real professional criticism.

It's nice that you think you know how everyone who doesn't spout endless compliments feels about music and their favored artists, but you're so off base it's just ridiculous. None of us would tell Kuu to her face that the album sucks, obviously. That's not the proper outlet for criticism. I'm not even sure why you're trying to imply that it's somehow lousy or two-faced to criticize someone's work and then not bitch to the artist's face. Uh, we're still fans, whether we like everything the artist puts out or not.

Regardless, her career extends far beyond a single album, and if we weren't fans of her as an artist in general none of us would be wasting our times sampling the album to begin with. Do you seriously think that just because someone criticizes an album they're haters? Are you really THAT thin-skinned that you're personally offended when someone criticizes the work of an artist you like??? To call people trolls and haters simply because they criticize an album that, BTW, a large percentage of people have described as formless noise? It's not as if one or two people are just pulling insults out of their asses to be mean. When you have a good percentage of legitimate fans making the same complaint about an album, odds are usually there's an actual problem with it, even if best case scenario it is just a polarizing album.

If people were coming in here and calling her a talentless hack or other personal jabs, that'd be one thing. But to imply that people have no right to criticize the music she put on an album is just... wow. No more words lol.