Quote:
Originally Posted by Corvina
@ Zeke:
I do know what you wanted to say. And you are right. But nobody can be 100% objective. We're all human and because of our experiences our taste is formed and we gonna respond accordingly. Feelings are just part of being human - the main part actually, that's why music works so well.
Also music is a form of art. Art and art reception is highly subjective.
The only thing somebody with the right background can judge is the technique behind something. But perfectionism mostly destroys "good" art. If you know what I mean.
I guess SKYia just wanted to stress, how rude some people express their dislike, especially on the internet. I actually had a PM with Koumori speaking about it as well - I guess pretty much nobody would be so rude in real life about something like they express it here on the forum here and there.
And that's the only thing I personally really ask for - an adequate way of wording your opinion. No matter if you dislike or like something.
|
I know it is difficult to be 100% objective, but it is hard to have a true critique when you are not sure how much of it is based off of love for the artist and how much of it is based off of love for the product. For me, it is rather easy to separate the two, and I guess that is why I am comfortable expressing myself in a manner that can be considered rude. Of course many of us would never say these things to the artist, Hell I'd actually be way more inclined to have it out with the composers and arrangers because that's where 85% of the blame goes (although Ku's voice is a bit of a negative factor this time around), but I think we all choose to express ourselves in a way that is consistent with the emotions we feel and with the intensity in which we feel them.