|
I just got my TA box set of A ONE. It's all a bit crammed in. The design of the CDL artwork is terrible, but the booklet for A ONE is gorgeous.
I can confirm that Yuta Nakano is credited as arranging Tell All.
The Tell All version is very different. It starts off with a piano intro and the first verse is sung over the piano. Strings are introduced, the first chorus doesn't have any guitars- more strings, and a snare drum playing an army beat, and a bell.
The original arrangement is introduced slowly in the second verse and then the second chorus has the guitars (but not as strong) and backing vocals. The rest of the song is pretty much the same, just not as harsh as the original.
I'm not sure how it rates to the original... I love the song as a composition but I think both arrangements fall flat. The programmed guitars and strings make it sound too anime-ish and contrived. It needed a more organic production like a GUILTY-era song. Also, not a fan of the additional echo/reverb on her voice in this version.
__________________
CDL 2010.12.31 * CDL 2011.12.29-31 * AT 2012.07.28, 08.11-12
AT 2013.07.13 * CDL 2014.12.30-31 * AT 2015.06.06-07
TA 2015.10.19-20 * AT 2016.05.15 *AT 2017.06.17-18, 29
|