^I agree with you on every single point, very good argumentation.
To some people the music from her 2005-2006 era isn't very appealing, thus they probably don't get the same feel for the music as with the earlier music they really enjoyed - what you yourself feel about the songs is important aswell when you judge how emotional it is as the emotional-ness of the song has to effect you for you to feel it. I have a hard time seeing how
is this LOVE? could not be seen as emotional when I'm presented with no furter argument than that it is obnoxious wailing
.