[LacusClyne]

Originally Posted by Keishi

Too bad. Considering this is an Ayu forum, you can expect a giant amount of votes on Secret. Both albums may be great to each of the fans. Secret may appeal much to Pop-Rock lover Ayumi Hamasaki fans. While Black Cherry may appeal much to Urban R&B Pop Koda Kumi fans. You can expect a lot of bad reviews from this forum, why? Because majority is Ayumi Hamasaki fans. Who OF COURSE prefer Secret. They have to ensure their queen have most votes. (And also, because their musical preference is of course, Ayumi Hamasaki)



Check out Honey Flash's thread about Black Cherry.
http://honeyflash.cloudwalking.net/v...id=2151&page=1

You can see how impressed those Koda Kumi fans with Black Cherry. Because their musical preferences are to Koda. If we put similar poll, I'm sure Black Cherry will conquer Secret.

So...........an accurate poll comparing J-Pop artist, shouldn't be done in any specific artist forum. Where's the fairness in that?
Poll like this should be going on general jpop forum. Not in Hamasaki Ayumi forum.

you're right. someone should really start this thread in jpopsuki or other forum, then we shall see the result.

anyway, lucky i did not have my hopes too high for black cherry, i'm most interested to see the drama more then anything, so i find the album not bad.
i had already like 'koi no tsubomi', 'With Your Smile', I'll be there', 'Ningyo hime', 'Unmei', 'Cherry Girl'. 'Won't be Long just sound weird without EXILE while 'Twinkle' could be better with kuu's pronouce. i don't think i will understand it if i don't have the lyrics!!!!! from the album track, i love 'Get Up & Move', the others i still have to get another listen.

while ayu's Secret, i had like all 4 single tracks. then, i was hooked to the whole album with all the album tracks too. ayu's vocals is stronger and better, i was very impressed that 'Secret' was recorded in a take!!!!!

overall, i'll vote for Secret.