Thoughts on PCDL '08-'09

[SunshineSlayer]

Originally Posted by Ayumi_lover

^well, i'm still fan of Ayu, ut I'm disappointed in this show, but I have to admit that because it's really long and problems with Ayu's hand they recorded lipsynch to more songs than planned

I don't know what her hand would have to do with her singing though. If anything, you would cut down more of the dancing, not the singing right? Plus I think thats a really short amount of time to have rerecorded those songs after the surgery.

Originally Posted by tenshi no hane

Still haven't seen it, but she sounds great! ^-^ I'm loving POWDER SNOW, especially the ending ~yuki yamu made~.

Personally I think it's all live, remember how upset she was when during Asia Tour 2007 some famous Chinese guy claimed she was lipsyncing? Ayu works hard to try reach perfection, so I doubt she would 'cheat' in such a way. (Though I can understand faking one or two songs with such a long setlist and an injury.)

Watch it first. Also, not saying that she did lip synch asia tour 2007 but it has been proven that she lip synched in the past and most likely lip synched at least Evolution at AT 07.

[yamogi]

Originally Posted by SunshineSlayer

I don't know what her hand would have to do with her singing though. If anything, you would cut down more of the dancing, not the singing right? Plus I think thats a really short amount of time to have rerecorded those songs after the surgery.



Watch it first. Also, not saying that she did lip synch asia tour 2007 but it has been proven that she lip synched in the past and most likely lip synched at least Evolution at AT 07.

Evolution is not lip synced...No one has proved that....

[SunshineSlayer]

Originally Posted by yamogi

Evolution is not lip synced...No one has proved that....

Check the enquiries section. It is most likely. But that wasn't the proven instance I was speaking of anyways.

[Melrose]

Originally Posted by yamogi

Evolution is not lip synced...No one has proved that....

Actually, I did, but then everyone ignored the subject after that~

BTW the ANGEL'S SONG bridge IS live, but the song itself is lip sync lol.

[ihulk2]

Originally Posted by SunshineSlayer

I don't know what her hand would have to do with her singing though. If anything, you would cut down more of the dancing, not the singing right? Plus I think thats a really short amount of time to have rerecorded those songs after the surgery.


Watch it first. Also, not saying that she did lip synch asia tour 2007 but it has been proven that she lip synched in the past and most likely lip synched at least Evolution at AT 07.

Well, if she's in pain, even if she's dancing less than usual, surely its possible her singing might be affected ? Give her a break, she was brave enough to go ahead and do the show so as not to disappoint the fans, surely that deserves our support, if nothing else ? Criticize constructively, but also remember Ayu is human, and not some machine. Cutting down one part does not balance up or have no effect on another.

So let's say you're correct, she lip synched on numerous occasions although she denies doing so. I give her the benefit of the doubt.
She may have lip-synced at AT07, ok, there's no smoke without fire. But I also believe that we do not know the full story behind all this lip synching, but I CHOOSE to believe in Ayu, knowing how much lip synching amounts to a betrayal, to simply cheating her fans.