COUNTDOWN LIVE 2010-2011 A ~do it again~ information thread [II]

[hidekirby]

Originally Posted by Chritopher

30.12!!!

She sounds the same here and on the TV version. Even if these are two different dates.

If I have to trust a live recording I will definitely trust the TV one... and these 2 vids comfort my opinion.

[Chritopher]

Originally Posted by hidekirby

She sounds the same here and on the TV version. Even if these are two different dates.

If I have to trust a live recording I will definitely trust the TV one... and these 2 vids comfort my opinion.

Then you might consider listening one more time.
One can hear difference even in the first note in Last Angel!!
It's OK here but on 31.12 it was off-key.
Well, I think I'm lucky that I sing myself and can easily notice such differences.
I'm not trying to say that many users are tone-deaf but some of you really can't hear differences, don't hear pitch correction in edited versions of the songs, etc and try to convince the guys who do hear that we're wrong. Funny situation, no offences.

[hidekirby]

Originally Posted by Chritopher

Then you might consider listening one more time.
One can hear difference even in the first note in Last Angel!!
It's OK here but on 31.12 it was off-key.
Well, I think I'm lucky that I sing myself and can easily notice such differences.
I'm not trying to say that many users are tone-deaf but some of you really can't hear differences, don't hear pitch correction in edited versions of the songs, etc and try to convince the guys who do hear that we're wrong. Funny situation, no offences.

I think you got me wrong. I didn't say they were exactly the same! I just said that she didn't sound great on both recordings. I also think that dvd are overly edited. (which is not really a bad thing though). I'm sure her performance on dvd will sound flawless...