Sparkle vs. ECSTASY (PV ONLY)

[elepop]

Originally Posted by noidea

Sparkle PV is the worst example for Ayu being sexy, and I still think itm coming off so bad has two reasons: a) I think this PV was supposed to be a parody of the likes of Lady Gaga(but the director was too bad to show that) and b) the director is horrible
ans seriously, if in the middle of cutie honey(or was it butterfly? i forgot) theres suddenly stripper poles coming out of the ground and she does more moaning than singing for the rest of that song that is ****ty for me, though I dont blame it on her, thats more of avex fault

Why do people always think that Ayu's bad PVs are parody?
They are not. They are just really bad PVs.

[ayumi.hamasaki]

ECSTASY

[Teppei-chan]

Ecstasy
I think I like the PV a bit more then Sparkle. I didn't like some parts of the Sparkle PV

[hearted]

ECSTASY BABY!!!! (though if this was about the song, i wouldve chosen sparkle)

[Andrenekoi]

Originally Posted by Crystal_Ageha

^^ Lol. I can't imagine finding any reason to debate that Sparkle is a parody in any sense. =_=' The only one I've ever said was a parody is Startin', and I definitely stand by that...

Anyway, how can anybody--or, at least the majority choose Sparkle over ECSTASY??? I can see if you like Sparkle - I like it, just because it's so weird and makes me giggle - but how can you honestly say it's better than ECSTASY? D: Especially if we're talking about sexy... Sparkle was just awkward, not sexy, lol. ^^'

Well, there's something called "opinion", and thanks good, usually everybody has a different one...

IMO Ecstasy makes me think too much about Because of You, while Sparkle is a interesting comment about japanese popstars... About Ayu looking to be "trying too hard", I always find it interesting that people around here never consider that that would be the main idea of the video: looking over the top

[AyUta]

Wow, they're so close >_<;

[Sadette]

Sparkle is better imo

[Miduhyo]

I went with sparkle. But it was a close one!

[asmAyumi1992]

Sparkle

[happiholic★]

I didn't like Ecstasy all that much. I think I like Sparkle more, not just because I do think it's a better video in general, but I like that it was something new and unexpected from Ayu.

Random Edit: I have learned to quite enjoy Ecstasy, but I still stand by my vote. I like Sparkel from Ayu because its still something she has never done, and probably will never do again, though I wish she would.

[y_nathz]

Sparkle for me..
but this poll is kinda hard lol

[Baernash]

I like both but Sparkle more. ECSTASY is quite similar to other Koda PVs.

[Chandrachan]

I LOVE SPARKLE but I'd say ECSTASY has the more sexier PV

[Pieces_of_SEVEN]

ECSTASY in terms of PV.

[2Hurt]

Ecstasy

[lovelism]

Sparkle~

[Mirrorcle Monster]

Sparkle

[CHE.R.RY]

Ayu

I really have not been into Kuu's stuff for awhile now...PVs are no exception lol.

[VRGRK]

ECSTASY is much better done than Sparkle. Even though there really isn't a theme per-say going on in ecstasy it's a more pleasant to watch over Sparkle, which screams po-R-n star to me, not to mention it's just disturbing; I mean it makes because of you look classy...I don't know how to explain it... it just does.

[adantatu2]

Sparkle, the hottest ayu PV ever