Hold It Against Me PV vs Born This Way PV

[AyumiAi]

Hold it against me is terrible born this way is at least interesting lol funny enough both music videos are directed by the same guy

[YuriChan]

^Actually, they're not directed by the same guy. Hold It Against Me's Video was directed by the same guy that directed Gaga's Telephone video.

[Pieces_of_SEVEN]

HIAM? seriously? It was so boring.

[PoetGirl]

HIAM is a real pv. Its fun to watch, it has some story there, britney is truly a queen there, while BTW is like... a big fail. I understand where gaga is coming from, but it was ugly to watch, she doesnt look good, why being naked all the time, and those horror scenes are just lame, and especially parts with MJ. you cant have a king in your disgusting video gaga. it was very offensive.

[happiholic★]

HIAM. I'm not loving BTW in any size, shape or form.

[YuriChan]

NEITHER!!! Hold It Against Me was interesting the first few times... But it loses my attention after a while. Born This Way was both interesting, a little trippy, a little disgusting, and a draaaag. I like that Hold It Against Me had a doppelganger but Born This Way had an interesting beginning! lol But that's just me.

[TeamAyu2004]

Born this Way.. love the concept!

[Melodie]

Hold It Against Me, because it's easier on the eyes.

[brener]

hold it against me.

[ll moments ll]

Born This Way. it's far more interesting, gritty, and i liked the visuals.

Hold It Against Me was 1 big advertisement. it's hard to look past the blunt product placement everywhere. there was product placement in Telephone, but at least it had a storyline. at least Britney looked pretty in it. i'm not really digging the new Britney era. sounds too much like Ke$ha/Katy Perry (not surprised since Max Martin/Dr. Luke is making most of the songs).

[emi♡]

Originally Posted by Pieces_of_SEVEN

HIAM? seriously? It was so boring.

seriously.

It doesn't even compare in any way.

It's funny how obvious it is in videos and songs, when one artist has talent and another does not, when they're using the same people.

[Aditmi Krisnasaki ~II~]

HIAM ftw!

[koumori]

Originally Posted by love in music

overall hold it against me is better. the born this way MV confirmed to me she's a try hard and nothing more than that. not that britney is much better.. but just sayin'. I can't wait until everyone is over her.

It's obvious you're not a fan anyway. "she's a tryhard and nothing more than that"...well, she puts so much effort into every release. If she was just a "tryhard" or w/e then she'd just copy off others for fame. All I see is Lady Gaga living, breathing, her work. If you don't like it then fair enough, but no need to be all sour and "I can't wait until everyone is over her" lol

[Cherry Dynamite]

Personally song wise I like Hold It Against Me more but its music video is a bit bland and the editing was terrible to say the least but I still liked it. I was initially disappointed by Born This Way because I thought it sounded like something Madonna would record and not too mention it tries to hard to be anthemy but honestly the video was awesome and it made me love the song.

[MemorialAddress]

Neither.
I'm beyond sick of GaGa and her lame attempts at being "original" and "herself". It's so old and not entertaining anymore. And no, I'm not just some random GaGa hater either. I used to really love her :/
I love Brit, but the HIAM video really sucks. BIG TIME.

[Aditmi Krisnasaki ~II~]

I'm kinda bored with those sensational/bombastic things Lady GaGa have done with her fashion, music, or PV..

yes, she's original and beyond creative to express her feelings but I think it's time to be conventional / normal again now...

all her songs are just like all about motivational messages to LGBT people on and on and on... T__T

[Nukaru]

HIAM, not because I'm a Britney Fan, I just don't get why Lady Gaga has to be naked all the time.. It's getting old. She really should put some clothes on and maybe than, I'd start to take her seriously again.
Right now, to me, she's nothing more than those rappers, that need half-naked girls, cars and drugs in their videos, to be 'cool' and 'in'. Cheap. Being original is good, being creative is even better, but if you're just going to be half-naked in almost all videos, it's nothing at all.

Britney really tried with HIAM and the video even has some kind of story. Gaga tried to make an anthem for the LGBT community, but I don't think that really worked this time.



PS: Gaga & Brtiney Stans, everyone has their own opinion, accept that fact.

Born This Way's little opening was too long. I really didn't like the visuals either.

I liked HIAM. It was nothing special, but it was a nice little video. I don't know, maybe I'm a little biased. Listening to Britney brings me back to my youth. lol

Anyway, I think Born This Way is catchier in terms of the song, but I didn't like the video.

[Oniisan]

Born This Way♥

[amorphose]

Even though I think BTW is Lady GaGa's weakest video yet, it's still better than Hold It Against Me.