HEART STATION vs. Guilty vs. Kingdom!
 

Which J-diva's 2008 album do you like the best? For me it's pretty obvious... HEART STATION! :love

Awww! DD: Why didn't you add BoA? THE FACE was totally HOTT! :yes Also, you beat me making this thread! :laugh I can't choose yet because I haven't heard HEART STATION but if it was between Ayu and Kuu's album, I would choose Kuu simply because Kuu had a better quality of music than Ayu. I like Ayu's rock music but GUILTY wasn't as good as I had hope it to be. Kingdom was HAWT! I enjoy every bit of the album and those who say that Black Cherry was better than Kingdom, must be on crack to think that. (no your not! lol)

Kingdom

Also my rankings would be:

01. HEART STATION (10/10)
02. Guilty (I feel like Ayumi put a lot of emotion into this album)
03. Kingdom (the only decent album track is "Under")

HEART STATION 09/10
GUILTY 06/10
KINGDOM 02/10 (sorry i hate this ALBUM !!!)

I won't vote yet, I will wait until I make up a solid opinion about it.

I already can tell that for me it will be GUILTY or HEART STATION, I extremely loved most of the songs on both albums and they both are pretty strong.
For Kingdom I extremely loved only half of the album tracks, I didn't like a lot of tracks who seem like fillers and the cute songs much and it's definitely not one of the strongest albums of kumi, but it is better than her Black Cherry and feel my mind.

I voted GUILTY. At first I wasn't that fond of it... didn't like that many of the single tracks. But I feel like the album as a whole was well put together and the songs seem like thought and effort was put into them. I like Hikki, but HEART STATION was sooo monotonous. There were some good tracks like Take 5 but I'm not one for slow songs usually and the whole album used virtually the same instrumentation, tempo, and everything. Still, decent. As for KINGDOM, well, to be blunt, Koda Kumi has kinda sucked since her BEST 2 album. Kinda unfortunate because i LOVED her stuff up till then. And believe me, I try very hard to like every oversexed female artist I find lol

I voted HEART STATION. My list goes like this in order from greatest to least:

HEART STATION
GUILTY
Kingdom

They're all fantastic albums though.

Kingdom - 9/10
HS - 8.5/10
GUILTY - 8/10

Pretty close, they were all hot albums imo. I don't think there will be a release season were I like all the diva albums that drop again.

HEART STATION
Guilty
Kingdom -> the only song I like is More o_O

GUILTY = 10/10
HEART STATION = 7/10
Kingdom = 5/10

I actually like BoA's THE FACE BEST XD

anyway, from the list above

1.Guilty
2.Kingdom
3.Heart station

hikki failed to suprise me this time :(

GUILTY
HEART STATION

And no Kuu.
No thanks.

Without a question, HEART STATION is the best.
GUILTY was good for a month
Kingdom just plain sucked.

GUILTY = 9.0/10
HEART STATION = 8.5/10
Kingdom = 0/10

Well, none of those are my favorites albums of 2008. 'THE FACE', 'WISH' and 'the brilliant green complete singles collection' are so much better than these ones. Sorry Ayu, Hikki and Kuu but you weren't my favorites in this year.

Between those three albums I'll choose GUILTY.

HEART STATION I guess. GUILTY was good and Kingdom was crap.

1-GUILTY > 10/10
2-HEART STATION > 9.9/10
3-Kingdom > 6.9/10

Kingdom was pretty bland...

On first listening ; HEART STATION 9/10 GUILTY 9/10 Kingdom 8.5/10
Sebsequent listening; 9/10 8/10 5.5/10

I love almost all the songs in HS and GUILTY, and half of the songs in Kingdom.

But Kingdom kinda become boring after a period of time whereas songs in HS and GUILTY won't. HS is a less complex ablum compared to GUILTY and also it seems to flow better and thus i voted for HEART STATION.

^^Um, Austin...I love you, but even I think that was a bit much. :rolleyes XD

I have yet to hear HEART STATION, so I won't vote just yet. I'm holding off until a day when I can just sit down and do something on my computer and put it on in the background, because I keep hearing disappointing things about it. :/