POLL: Is your liking of a song affected by the MV for that song?

[AyumiAi]

Question to all the AHS memebers here!
Have you ever based weather you like a song or not based on its
music video? (if it does have a music video obviously)
For example i really didnt like the music video for Sweet Season, except for the end part of it, which i thought was really great, but i would have prefered
more Ayu singing as opposed to little kids, but anyways.This kind of turned me off from the song. When i got my L single, i basically listened to VR and LA
and didnt listen much to SS, but then i actually just listened to the song itself
and i have fallen in love with the song.
Has this ever happened to you? Like you like a song because of its mv or not like a song because of it MV?

Sweet Seasons' PV was also lackluster and boring for me except for the beginning where the kids call her "Mom" and the end where she awakens with the rocker outfit on...Ayumi is the only singer where her PVs and songs usually match....so I'd say yeah in her case, a PV and a song that match usually influence the liking of a song.

[love in music]

not really. if it's an amazing song i'll still love it if it comes out with a crappy PV. a big example here is the TO BE pv. that video is one of the worst i have ever seen but the song is so amazing and the PV can't take anything away from that. i also find myself not being able to like a song just because of its PV.. i mean the PV can make listening to the song more tolerable but once i listen to it without the PV i'll still be reminded of what a bad song it is. another example would be the ourselves PV, it's one of the best i have ever seen but i still do not like that song and won't listen to it outside of the PV.

[bondingo]

It really depends on the situation for me. Some songs I just love so much that the PV doesn't affect my liking of it at all, whereas other times an amazing video will make me like the song that much more because I'll associate them. It works the opposite way sometimes as well, but that doesn't happen nearly as often. I actually don't think that's ever been the case with an Ayu PV (a bad PV making me like a song less that is).

[kirei_ayumi]

nope, not at all. like for me, who cares if the mv is good or not, its really about the song

No, not really. I don't really like is this LOVE?, but the PV is one of my favorites.

[freedreamer]

hmmm...because I associate songs with colours, the PV does affect the colour i see that song in LOL (sorry im a bit weird in this aspect).
but there are indeed some songs that are so good, a PV doesnt take away much from it (for me, the one that comes off most recent is crossroad)

[MiiSan]

Originally Posted by freedreamer

hmmm...because I associate songs with colours, the PV does affect the colour i see that song in LOL (sorry im a bit weird in this aspect).

LOL! That's exactly how I view a song Like when I listened to BALLAD for the first time (before watching the PV) I imagined it with shades of red and green and being dark, now after I watched the PV, I can't get the pink and shades of dark red out of my mind

Other than that... it does actually change a bit the song, the song will stand out more for me (not really with ayu in this case though, more like with other artists) either if the PV is bad or not, i will probably still love the song XD

[BlackSilence]

Not at all... i can love the song but hate the video. For example I absolutelly love Dearest, but I really don't like the video.

[hsienko]

The only time a PV really affects my opinion of a song is if I'm on the fence and I'm not sure if I like a song or not, a good PV can push me to like it. Also the PV effects what images I see in my head when I think about and listen to the song.

[jon_the_d]

sometimes a good pv can make me like a song more, but otherwise no. they never make me like a song less...

except maybe Lady dynamite.

[LastAngel]

Originally Posted by jon_the_d

sometimes a good pv can make me like a song more, but otherwise no. they never make me like a song less...

This. Plus, sometimes when I don't like a song and then I watch a pv, it makes me like a song because I could relate the song to something.

[jbrat2219]

Nope, not really. With Ayu, I generally am very black and white. I either like the song or I don't, only time can change that not a PV.

[butterfly_ayu]

sometimes, depends on how good the pv is (like I didn't love Rule very much the first time I heard it, but the pv just turned out to be great, and I liked it more then). but usually a good pv never makes me like a song that I don't like in the first place~

[visionfactory]

YES, SO MUCH

I don't mind listening to MOON because I had a bad imrpession of the song after watching the PV

[rakeru]

Definitely. Mostly, it helps me realize the true potential of a song, but in rare cases it may discourage a song. I wouldn't have appreciated ourselves or Because of you if they didn't have such amazing PVs. I would have been better off without Sparkle or Lady Dynamite's PVs.

[pommy48]

Not really~ There are some boring PVs, but I just don't watch them. I still like the PV, but if it has a bad PV, the PV doesn't really affect my opinion of the song

But if I don't like a song at first and I watch the PV and love the PV, then I usually end up liking the song~

[happiholic★]

Not really. At one or two times the PV has made me like the song more, but it's not a consistent thing.

[anayufan]

there are definitely cases this has happened with me for other artists but with ayu it's hard cuz i mostly like her music to begin with. so maybe on a less extreme level, i can like an ayu song MORE because of the pv... but hardly is there ever an ayu song i liked solely after seeing the pv.

but how about another side to the discussion? especially with her newer ones, sometimes an ayu song makes the PV better or worse! for example Don't look back's PVis really boring and since i heard the song first i was expecting something better/different. in that sense, the song ruined the PV... it was too good for that boring video xD. and for the case of a song helping a PV, well i think Daybreak is a good example! the remix is one of my favorite ayu songs and watching mummy ayu make the sky brighter, darker, brighter, darker over and over again in the video would've been so boring if i wasn't listening to that remix at the same time!

[asmAyumi1992]

Sometimes. When the first time I listen to VR, I dont think it would be my favorite. but when I watched the pv, the song grew in me rapidly