taskinst vs. Don't tell me by Hoobastank

[GRACE]

Originally Posted by Coelacanth

Maybe Ayu found out, and that's why tasuku had no involvement in GUILTY. That's a shame, because he's an excellent arranger. As a composer.. not so great.

I definately side with you here, I suddenly realized how strange it was that TASUKU has had an intrelude on every album since I am...(minus, strangely, MY STORY, and Memorial address which has no interludes), and suddenly he's out of the picture on GUILTY. This almost makes me wonder about his other interludes...

It's upsetting though, especially because amongst ignorant fans, Ayu will be the one who's blamed.

[Lora-Ayu]

Originally Posted by GRACE

It's upsetting though, especially because amongst ignorant fans, Ayu will be the one who's blamed.

Some ignorant fans/people might even tag Ayu again as a copycat (since it's in her album). So, I do hope they won't.

And some more people are starting to conclude about something they're not even sure of, (I mean, yes, they're sure that it sounds the same but do we truly know the whole story behind it?)

Oh well, the Taskinst sounds better for me though.

[DestinyWishes]

Woah, it's exactly the same, I was expecting better from Tasuku. I can't believe taskinst isn't his work.

[bakacat]

This is quite surprising, and quite disappointing on tasuku's part. Maybe he did work on it before, but I don't really think so because Secret was a mini-album from the beginning, and when they changed it to a full album there must've been not much time left, so maybe he took some inspiration from this song? XD I still like the arrangement of taskinst, though.

[Chibi_Venus]

I know it sounds, like, 98% alike, but there's no confirmation on whether or not tasuku completely took Hoobastank's work, right? I'm just saying, because some people seem to be jumping to conclusions.

Anyway, I never really liked "taskinst" in the first place, so it's not like I'm thinking, "Ohh, I've lost my love for it," you know? Now, if "tasking" was found to be copied, I'd be devastated. ()

[minkAYuko]

Damned TASUKU!!!, I've never been fan of that song much! xD.

TASUKU is now #2 on the list of composers who should not work with ayu NEVER AGAIN!, GEO is number #1.

[DOLCE]

^ yeeees. I still love Taskinst

[Larisa-chan]

Aw man, I loved this interlude, too!!! Bleh, so disappointed.

[Rurutia]

oh man I really liked taskinst.......shame on you tasuku

[truehappiness]

I think that tasuku shouldn't really be said to "never work with Ayu again" because it seems like a lot of people do this..

I mean, there are a lot of accusations against Ai Otsuka and her own compositions and no one does anything about it :\

[ayumisrael]

LOL though it sounds the same taskinst is still awesome

[GRACE]

We don't know when TASUKU wrote taskinst. For all we know he could have had it for years and years, and just was waiting for the right oppertunity to employ it.

[milky_way]

It doesn't make me like taskinst any less.

[Kikaru]

I liked Tasuku as a composer, not just for Ayu. But it could explain the weird absence from the GUILTY album, if Avex/Ayu found out or something...

[ALPHY]

Originally Posted by Kikaru

But it could explain the weird absence from the GUILTY album, if Avex/Ayu found out or something...

Lolol. It's likely. XDDD

[alternarist]

Originally Posted by Kikaru

But it could explain the weird absence from the GUILTY album, if Avex/Ayu found out or something...

lol!! nice one!!

but i must say the only thing that is similar is the transition from soft to loud (rock） part.. thats all.

[TITANIC]

eew tasuku.. need his clue..

[Melrose]

OMG... Pride and Crucified really ARE a lot alike!!

Crucified:
http://video.google.com/videoplay?do...B5KgjQL5g6S7DA

@alternarist: Um.. Almost the whole thing is the same.. @_@

[Namie]

I thought that Ayu had super controll over her work. That she goes through every song carefully. I guess not huh..that sounded EXACTLY the same.

[ownsarai]

Originally Posted by Namie

I thought that Ayu had super controll over her work. That she goes through every song carefully. I guess not huh..that sounded EXACTLY the same.

The thing is, Ayu doesn't know about every composition in the world, therefore she could have let it pass without even knowing about it. I still think the composer(s) are at fault for this kind of thing. I'll say it again, CREA needs to come back, and SOON~