![]() |
| · Ayu's Official Site · Ayu's twitter · Ayu's YouTube · masa's translations · Misa-chan's translations · |
|
|
|
#1
|
||||
|
||||
|
I'm personally not a fan of her more sporadic/dramatic acting, like in Flower -- I prefer more subtle. That said, she is clearly doing it purposefully and that is fine.
So many people hating on Flower who probably think Mirrorcle World is brilliant, when she's doing the same thing. |
|
#2
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
and she still nailed it! i wish people here were on industry and made their perfect 1M$ 3months shooting videos
|
|
#3
|
|||
|
|||
|
Lol I don't think these videos are meaningless -- sure, there's meaning and intent behind them -- but I think that they are just lame as fuck. There, I said it.
There's nothing remotely interesting or innovative about the execution, nor does she seem to have anything remotely interesting to say. For those who say that this era is about doing 'simple' - yea, like how she basically dug deep into the recesses of her complex soul to decide that a clean shot of her smiling at the camera is the most groundbreaking concept ever for the covers of the TA edition of the album, amirite? There's nothing wrong with a simple, pared down video. I think Utada Hikaru's PV for "Hikari" was simple but beautifully executed (and I am always first and foremost an Ayu fan before I am a Hikki fan). I honestly feel like she should have just released the album WITHOUT any PVs because the existence of these videos is seriously marring my experience of the album. Flower is such a powerful song, and watching her flail like that just undercuts everything with humour for me. Can't take it seriously at all. EDIT: Rewatched the Flower clip again JUST to see if there are any redeeming factors that I might have missed out on and all I can uncover are EVEN more flaws, like the false start to the vocal part just before she starts singing at the start, like she was gonna sing too early and changed her gestures to save it. It's like they couldn't even be arsed to do a new take to rectify that. -_- Last edited by js_surrealism; 17th June 2016 at 08:04 PM. |
|
#4
|
||||
|
||||
|
wait what? you are an ayu fan? i've never seen you say anything good about her
|
|
#5
|
|||
|
|||
|
Quote:
One can be a fan of an artist without having to blindly love everything she does, especially when there are clear deficiencies in the work... |
|
#6
|
||||
|
||||
|
The thing is it's sort of forbidden to criticize any aspects of her work or reveal unpleasant truth on this forum unless you want to be attacked by diehard fans who can't respect opinions different from theirs.
__________________
ex-TeamAyu member Ayu concerts I've been to (22): ARENA TOUR 2012 ~HOTEL Love songs~ (11.08, 12.08 (Fukuoka) COUNTDOWN LIVE 2012-2013 ~WAKE UP~ (29.12, 30.12, 31.12) 15th Anniversary TOUR ~A BEST LIVE~ (11.05, 12.05 (Yokohama), 15.05, 16.05 (Osaka) COUNTDOWN LIVE 2013-2014 A (29.12, 30.12, 31.12) COUNTDOWN LIVE 2014-2015 A, Cirque de Minuit (29.12, 30.12, 31.12) ARENA TOUR 2015 Cirque de Minuit ~真夜中のサーカス~(11.04, 12.04 Saitama) COUNTDOWN LIVE 2015-2016 A ~MADE IN TOKYO~ (29.12, 30.12, 31.12) COUNTDOWN LIVE 2016-2017 A『Just the beginning -20-』(29.12, 30.12) |
|
#7
|
||||
|
||||
less is more
__________________
~Ayu @-->--~ |
|
#8
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
As Ayu says in Mad World, tbh.... This era makes me sick to my stomach.
__________________
|
|
#9
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
"She is lazy/ She doesn't care anymore/ This is so bad I'm surprised anyone like it/ She is embarassing/ I hope she could retire so she would stop to hurt her legacy/ This is shit/ This is garbage/ It feels like she is surrounded by yesmen who agree with any bad idea she has" = not ok Also is not ok to act like your subjective opinion is a scientific fact. |
|
#10
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
Quote:
![]() ==== one thing for sure, when you have such divided opinions about something, that's art right there lol. sorry to say, but something which has no meaning to person A doesn't mean it does NOT have meaning objectively. That's like saying a monument with historical significance has no meaning for you simply because you did not go through a certain era but you cant say it has NO MEANING at all because it does stand for something. And I think these videos do stand for something. Why not compare it to BLUE BIRD and see if that PV means anything. and i think some people really ought to READ about the various interpretations around the thread. you are free to disagree but they are still interpretations, which to be honest, do make sense if you even bother thinking deeper than judge a video so shallowly. I even think the one-shot amateur-ish camera can have some sense. Yes, perhaps in a crude way, it's a really fast job because it's one take. But on another hand, it seems to even hint at how people are simply judging her in ONE WAY. Do you even look at ayu from another perspective? No. You judge her based on what you see on-screen. She must be poised and gentle? Heck no. Ayu doesn't want to conform. And, the deliberate monochromatic PV. You think it's lazy? Not at all. The mise-en-scène of the PV is incredible. Just look at the juxtaposition of ayu before and after. She was dressed in white. and then she gets dressed up by these tall people fully dressed in black. Almost suffocating because at one point, we only see her head. And then she wears a black gown. WHITE -> BLACK. It's so apparent. The symbolic use of colour and clothes. Lastly i wanted to say. All these comparison to her past works. Touch your heart and ask, Im sure she has had worse PVs. I found NaNaNa and Shake It and XOXO to be absolutely void of emotion and content. Of course, some people may find sense in it. These PVs may not be on the level of pre-Rock'n'Roll Circus but they sure come off with some aesthetic. It seems that Ayu has spoilt us with her magnificence post-MY STORY but honestly, i do agree these PVs remind me of her pre-MY STORY works more than anything. you can find meaning in anything, as long as you wish to. (ayu better be washing plates next PV. im sure everyones gonna love it) Last edited by freedreamer; 18th June 2016 at 04:52 AM. |
|
#11
|
||||
|
||||
|
Quote:
Also, just because she's doing something on purpose doesn't mean it's good LOL. She looks like a 12y/o singing karaoke in front of her webcam. The fact that people defend this let alone genuinely LIKE it makes me feel like I'm on a different planet from AHS. I'm embarrassed for you too sweetie Last edited by koumori; 17th June 2016 at 10:22 PM. Reason: edited in the double post |
![]() |
| Tags |
| flower, m(a)de in japan, mad world, made in japan |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |