ayu's songs...LIVE SUNG or RECORDED?

[souldoutt]

Originally Posted by ImaSuguHoshii

Sometimes I like live, sometimes I like recorded. They're all good to me

heh me too. But, a lot of the AT 2005 songs were the great live songs. And then there are the studiio recordings which, well, sound good due to editing

[pbs1605]

I prefer recorded songs over all.Not just for Ayumi but for anyone.

[g~sus~]

i would prefer most of (m)u's song recorded...

[Daking]

@Chibi_Venus or anyone else that can tell me, i've never heard her perfom And then live would u mind telling me where she does it?

[greggerz189]

I actually prefer Ayu live! I've been listening to her CDLs and AT mp3s nonstop for the past few days...Bold & Delicious at CDL was a m a z i ng !!!!

[HiruNoKaze]

She does And Then in one of the 2000 concerts. Ah, vol.1: http://www.eneabba.net/ayu/video/live/1.concert2000.htm

[Shiva]

well yeah,i like both.but honestly,i prefer lives better.i watched a live performance of angel's song and i was like "whoaa!! what a powerful voice!!"
she really has it you know!!

besides,if one wouldn't like her live vocals,why would that person even bother to go to her concerts?

[chibi_sunny]

^ Umm...to see her? Plus, her concerts (stage settings, etc) are amazing, even if she doesn't sound good. But Ayu definitely did improve a lot along the years.

For good quality, I prefer recorded. During lives, the instruments drown Ayu's singing, or vice versa. Also, her voice sounds too squeaky and high-pitched for my likeness. On the basis of emotion, her lives capture the intensity of her feelings.

[Shiva]

yeah well excuse me,but i wouldn't go to a concert if i didn't like how the singer sounds you know.

I like both but if I had to choose one I`d definetly say that I perfer her songs performed live. I just love her voice. It`s so soothing. And it feels better to listen to her real voice than her recorded voice. It feels more real. Ayu put`s more emotion into her live performances. I love it!

[animefanatic002]

i like both actually. like the my story concert she had. the vocals were amazing!! but the recorded ones are great as well

[animefanatic002]

i like a lot of songs live...like step you, carols, boys and girls, replace, voyage and trauma

[shavoingin]

HONEY

[zeroshin888]

I love her live vocals. When she sings live, she just naturally give off this inexplicable attraction, for me at least and it makes you want more of her work sung live. I really liked most of the songs sung on AT05, it was just good! My most favourite live would be CAROLS @ Best Artist.

[immel]

I really do like hearing all of them live better than the CD tracks, the CD tracks are so dead compared to the live ones .

[truehappiness]

Dead? More like just a bit less alive. :<

-dead CD tracks-

[Kodayumi]

^^Lol..i would like STEP you and surreal to be live more than in the cds..i guess it has much more impact..

[Isthan]

A Song is Born, SURREAL (Stadium Tour 2002)
This concert actually made me love A Song Is Born.

Poker Face, M (A Museum)
That pink dress was one of the best costumes ever!

Duty, NEVER EVER, A Song For XX (Dome Tour 2001)
The best versions of Duty and NEVER EVER I've ever heard. I wish I could have these as an mp3. ASFXX is my favorite live performance. Nothing, NOTHING, can ever sound better than that.

[~X2RADialbomber~]

Her recorded songs suck compared to some of her Live Singing. Example: Bold And Delicious At CDL, Trauma at CDL, UNITE! at CDL

[AyuHamasaki01]

I dunno... uhm... I think her older songs from A Song for XX and LOVEppears ... yeah, but every live is different!

cause I love Vogue played at A-MUSEUM 2003 because the intro was extended! uhm... I like flower garden live

Conclusion: I love both LIVE + CD music but what i need to say about live is that it sounds different that is something I really like

(did this comment make any sense?)