Ayu's lives sounds flat?

[yoshino]

she did well enough in live shows.. but it seems like she is singing quite low.hmm..

[AyuGAME]

i thought her "part of me" performance at music station is one her best performance, i think she sings onkey and really controlled...but i don't know, everybody has their own opinion

[cater2u]

not all are perfects

[zoomzoom]

^The TV-version of a-nation 07 was great to me

[zeroshin888]

She probably sounded flat because her voice was just flat in general for that day since the quality of our voices are different everyday. It's also probably because she didn't do vocal exercises before singing like she would normally do so before recording or a concert.
I think Together when.. is quite a hard song to sing and control. Like what others have said, as long as it's not lip synched, it's all good~ XD

[octocoffee]

I dunno...I've never heard her like LIVE live. Her TV lives usually sound a bit off to me, even her some of her older performances. Her vibrato is being used a ton these days, but I like it most of the time ^_^ Her lives this year have been really off, but I think it's okay to have an 'off-year'. Ten years is a long time, after all. And I'm pretty sure we all know she's passed the peak of her career. Hopefully she'll have a LONG descent. As long as she tries her hardest, then I'm okay.

[ayumixfan]

I liked the Together When live performance XD! lol I think she is a hit or miss XP lol sometimes I LOVE her live and sometimes I REALLY hate it lol

[Aggar]

mina , do you all still like Ayu? as for me . . I like her no matter what is happening to her . . .

[AyuGAME]

^agreed

[truehappiness]

Wow, I just watched some 2001 live of evolution, and oh my god it was... scary. D:

She's so much better now compared to 6 years ago. D:

[waterballoon]

Well, to add it on, in concerts she has her 2 back up singers (can't remember the names). They don't sing the whole song but you know they do sing at certain parts of the song. The two of them have completed the " 1 3 5" or better known as Doh Me Fah Chord with Ayu. Though I'm not certain if it's 1 3 5, 1 4 6, 1 5 7 or something else, her back up singers do complete some chord with her. As such, she won't sound very flat or anything.

[sora2522]

...you mean peco and princess?...








they're usually in almost every live with her...

[zoomzoom]

^ ... and they add scary "aaaaaahh aah ah aaaahhh~" sounds

[tinka69]

Okay, Ayu does not exactly have the greatest voice in the world. (It's unique though I must add, her old singing voice anyway...) and she's not very good at singing live. She does have good performances, but overall she's kind of shaky, especially on her tv show performances.