They forgot ayumi......

[Andrenekoi]

Originally Posted by Yoake

But Ayu acted in drama, she was a model before singing. She had AYUREADY as a TV show.

Ayu acted in drama.... when she was nobody
Ayu was a model... when she was a nobody

And Ayuready was shortlived and already resting in peace...

"Idol" in that sense, is not a title, but a profession... u can be a singer, a lawyer, a doctor, an idol... She had a short lived unsuccessful career as a idol, so, she can't be counted as one...

Idol in that sense is something closer to Paris Hilton, who acts, sings, models, etc, but is famous just for the sake of being famous... Even if some people in the list like Yamaguchi Momoe are really respected as musicians...