"Marionette" PV Discussion! - Page 2

darc_aqua · #21 27th December 2007, 12:17 AM

^ i agree Shuya's smile killed the mood of the PV

the angel song · #22 27th December 2007, 12:23 AM

I think Shuya's smile added a bit more creepiness IMO...it was fitting for his characteristic. And the white eyed glares from the other dancers...*shudders*

Ayumiko · #23 27th December 2007, 12:27 AM

I agree....even though his smile is freaky and ugly but it made the pv more creepy..he looked like he could be a serial murderer or something.

MemorialAddress · #24 27th December 2007, 12:39 AM

I thought it was great.
Thank god it wasn't another let down like (d)lma lololl
She looked so cute (when the contacts weren't in/when she was in normal clothes)

Qt Mashi · #25 27th December 2007, 12:46 AM

omg! finally a PV that's not cliche, stupid or tryhard dancing! it was really kool, time passed pretty quick while i was watching this because so many things were happening.

i love Ayu's hair, looks like a doll too

**milky_way** · #26 27th December 2007, 12:58 AM

I liked the creepiness of the PV, and Ayu looked great.

namiie · #27 27th December 2007, 01:23 AM

It was alright. Definitely not her best PV ever but still decent. I really like the direction and feel of the whole PV; the dark house to the wind to the way Ayu was tossing and turning. The whole "oh look we're puppets with scary eyes" bit got old really quickly though. I love the way they came alive though: eyes all broken.

The ending was a little stupid though. Ayu and co. all have this look in their faces like, "Bwahaha, we fooled her." Err, what? Like they HAD to pretend to be puppets and now they're ~alive~? So what? They're still tiny...I think a better ending would've been like this: Ayu leaves the room, closes the door. As she closes the door behind her and looks ahead: WHITE DRESS PUPPET AYU stands right in front of her. Real Ayu looks shocked. Zoom in on real Ayu's eyes, which then become all white and plastic. Real Ayu turns into the marionette; puppet Ayu has broken free. Cliffhanger! Of course, that's just me.

I do like Ayu's sense of style in this PV though. Both the white dress and the brown outfit were nice. And I really am loving that hair.

**milky_way** · #28 27th December 2007, 01:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by namiie

The ending was a little stupid though. Ayu and co. all have this look in their faces like, "Bwahaha, we fooled her." Err, what? Like they HAD to pretend to be puppets and now they're ~alive~? So what? They're still tiny...I think a better ending would've been like this: Ayu leaves the room, closes the door. As she closes the door behind her and looks ahead: WHITE DRESS PUPPET AYU stands right in front of her. Real Ayu looks shocked. Zoom in on real Ayu's eyes, which then become all white and plastic. Real Ayu turns into the marionette; puppet Ayu has broken free. Cliffhanger! Of course, that's just me.

I actually like your ending better than the one in the PV.

minna · #29 27th December 2007, 01:42 AM

what a great PV!!!
I love it !! even if it's really creepy XD
Shuya's smile was so scary! and with those eyes!!! O_O
it added more creepiness !!
when I watched it I was like : hope there is nobody behind me right now XD
no seriously it fits the song perfectly

987654321987 · #30 27th December 2007, 01:53 AM

best Pv since fairyland!
seriously! good make up+hair (without the which look @ part of me)
excellent story line
good dance moves
extremely dark....
what else are we expecting?

I am so looking forward to her performance of the song @ AT07 i think it wil be a spinning stage with similar dance moves!!! omg..... can't wait

Nu-NRG · #31 27th December 2007, 02:03 AM

this along with Together When... is the best for this year
there isn't much of a storyline but the creepiness make up for it :d
I love ayu's dark pv

the angel song · #32 27th December 2007, 02:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by namiie

I think a better ending would've been like this: Ayu leaves the room, closes the door. As she closes the door behind her and looks ahead: WHITE DRESS PUPPET AYU stands right in front of her. Real Ayu looks shocked. Zoom in on real Ayu's eyes, which then become all white and plastic. Real Ayu turns into the marionette; puppet Ayu has broken free. Cliffhanger! Of course, that's just me.

I do like Ayu's sense of style in this PV though. Both the white dress and the brown outfit were nice. And I really am loving that hair.

Cool idea! It could've still worked with the whole 'ayu's inner self waking her up from depression' because that puppet ayu could've been the 'ayu that broke free' in a literal sense AND add to the creepy factor.

Yukitora · #33 27th December 2007, 02:13 AM

I need a better rip but it looked enjoyable.

I must've missed shu-ya's smile

Bashumaru · #34 27th December 2007, 02:32 AM

I don't know why but I don't like this PV, I like (don't) leave me alone more than this. The song wasn't as great as I expected and the PV was pretty boring. I didn't get the end where they look like they were about to party and also Shuya's gross smile. Yuck!

veggie · #35 27th December 2007, 02:37 AM

Omg l loved it not her best but one of her best!!! l loved her dress, her hair, and her eyes! the consept of the video was great! l didnt much care for the ending l agree with namiie the ending could have been better! And namiie l love your ending so much better!!

Jwiz · #36 27th December 2007, 02:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by the angel song

I think Shuya's smile added a bit more creepiness IMO...it was fitting for his characteristic. And the white eyed glares from the other dancers...*shudders*

agreed

..and certainly it did not ruin the mood of the pv.

it was quite nice..not amazing but it's way better than the pv of glitter+fated+t2m..like the atmosphere and costumes but if the ending can be more defined it would be great..and impactbreaker' interpretation makes great sense; in the end the truth is finally able to take it's mask out.

SheFliesHigher · #37 27th December 2007, 03:47 AM

Woooo, I really liked it. Fit the mood of the song very nicely. Ayu's appearance and movements as a puppet were awesome. I also loved how she looked in that outfit with the vest. Her appearing in the TV was kind of random, though. And while the ending was amusing, I think it should have ended on a scary note, like the way Ourselves did.

WillofDusk · #38 27th December 2007, 04:01 AM

I love hte PV, it's really well made, intense and meaningful

**Love Appears** · #39 27th December 2007, 04:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SheFliesHigher

Her appearing in the TV was kind of random, though.

Yes. The "TV Ayu" looked fairly out of place. What was with the newsboy hat? I would've appreciated a more timeless look.

The real/non-miniature Ayu could've looked more surprised or at least fascinated by the marionettes.That's one of my main gripes.

I feel this PV and Together When... are the two most interesting PVs from the album. A little plot or eerie twist (think the faceless Ayu clone in Ladies' Night) would've spruced it up, but the choreography is pretty great. I especially like how the guy lifted Ayu in the air towards the end.

Kikaru · #40 27th December 2007, 05:16 AM

^Yeah, I thought that was a nice move. I like the dancing, because it was...well, actually nice and have a certain non-poppy element to it that I enjoyed. The eyes really freaked me, and Shuya's smile reminds me of a clown, but it's a good PV.

Although the TV was kinda random.