Thoughts on COUNTDOWN LIVE 2007-2008 Anniversary - Page 9

HilaryDuffFanboy · #**161** 3rd January 2008, 01:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by truehappiness

For the most part, DVDs ARE live. It is 100% Ayu's singing.

Don't let what UHPlus said get to you. If what he said was true, then his precious Namie Amuro DVDs aren't live either. :|

Yeah but they still edit it. There is no way she can ever do Ladies Night so that it resembles the CD version, but they will just edit it so that it sounds much better.

I do believe Ayu never lip syncs unless she is sick like in CDL 02-03. And why STEP you of all songs? It's not that hard to sing. So she'd lip STEP you but not the following Ladies Night which is really hard to do live? That isn't making much sense people.

Oh and by the way Namie Amuro is just one of the best ever live performers! She was freaking amazing with all the dancing and top notch singing.

truehappiness · #**162** 3rd January 2008, 01:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HilaryDuffFanboy

Yeah but they still edit it. There is no way she can ever do Ladies Night so that it resembles the CD version, but they will just edit it so that it sounds much better.

I do believe Ayu never lip syncs unless she is sick like in CDL 02-03. And why STEP you of all songs? It's not that hard to sing. So she'd lip STEP you but not the following Ladies Night which is really hard to do live? That isn't making much sense people.

True. I know it's edited, but she's still the one singing.

Ladies Night was electro anyway, performances of it probably.. wouldn't work out. I think Perfume's performances are kinda like that.. they're not totally lipsynched, but because of the electro element..

Huaka · #**163** 3rd January 2008, 01:06 PM

Yeah, that's right. If you listen to the concert in high quality earphones she sounds much better singing. Although Surreal was definitely the worst of the bunch, (and Evolution to me, but I never liked that song live except for the Dome Tour one) but her vocals weren't horrendous.

UHPlus · #**164** 3rd January 2008, 01:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by truehappiness

If what he said was true, then his precious Namie Amuro DVDs aren't live either. :|

yes! u r right!

e.g I WILL & toi et moi from SO CRAZY tour 2003-2004 , ALL FOR YOU from Space of Hip-Pop tour 2005

they are not her live vocal...i can tell cuz i can hear
it's pre-recorded cuz u can compare the performances with her previous n after songs...

as for ayumi..how can she went from 'nice perfect' vocal to 'horribly off-tune' in just a few songs and costumes changes?

did she accidentally drunk detergents when she's off stage?

truehappiness · #**165** 3rd January 2008, 01:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UHPlus

yes! u r right!

e.g I WILL & toi et moi from SO CRAZY tour 2003-2004 , ALL FOR YOU from Space of Hip-Pop tour 2005

they are not her live vocal...i can tell cuz i can hear
it's pre-recorded cuz u can compare the performances with her previous n after songs...

as for ayumi..how can she went from 'nice perfect' vocal to 'horribly off-tune' in just a few songs and costumes changes?

did she accidentally drunk detergents when she's off stage?

Some of the things you say are really out of line o_o;.

She probably couldn't sing her best anymore due to fatigue. :|

HilaryDuffFanboy · #**166** 3rd January 2008, 01:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UHPlus

yes! u r right!

e.g I WILL & toi et moi from SO CRAZY tour 2003-2004 , ALL FOR YOU from Space of Hip-Pop tour 2005
they are not her live vocal...i can tell cuz i can hear
it's pre-recorded cuz u can compare the performances with her previous n after songs...

as for ayumi..how can she went from 'nice perfect' vocal to 'horribly off-tune' in just a few songs and costumes changes?

did she accidentally drunk detergents when she's off stage?

That song is so live. I listened to an audio rip for months on end because I was bloody in love with it and I am sure it's live, it's so different to the studio version, Namie DVD's aren't edited anywhere near as much as Ayus.

Cys86 · #**167** 3rd January 2008, 01:16 PM

No matter what the truth is she needs to rest or it will definetely be the end of Ayu not becouse people will stop listen to her but she will damage her ear completely

UHPlus · #**168** 3rd January 2008, 01:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HilaryDuffFanboy

That song is so live. I listened to an audio rip for months on end because I was bloody in love with it and I am sure it's live, it's so different to the studio version, Namie DVD's aren't edited anywhere near as much as Ayus.

maybe i should say it's not live but it was edited alot..

if u watch namie's tv performances of ALL FOR YOU...then THAT is the real deal... the dvd's one sounded too smooth cuz namie's raw vocal is rather deep n coarse

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cys86

No matter what the truth is she needs to rest or it will definetely be the end of Ayu not becouse people will stop listen to her but she will damage her ear completely

i think what she need is some vocal training...she actually sounded pretty good back in 2000~2001 but after all these years it turned much much worse

**ayumisrael** · #**169** 3rd January 2008, 01:22 PM

People that were there actually enjoyed ayu's vocal performance so I don't have to say much about it.
I'm still waiting for it to finish download. It's 85%

truehappiness · #**170** 3rd January 2008, 01:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UHPlus

i think what she need is some vocal training...she actually sounded pretty good back in 2000~2001 but after all these years it turned much much worse

No... she was pretty baaaadd back then too. And if you didn't watch Docu of BEST of CDL, you should. She does a ton of vocal practice.

And stop making Cys86 all confused! Jeez!

People will NOT stop listening to Ayu because of a bad live. They aren't that coldhearted unless they're demonic or something and demand perfection.

**ayumisrael** · #**171** 3rd January 2008, 01:31 PM

I think that ayu's vocals became much better through the years much better than the vocals she had... It's just a matter of preferece I guess and how you like it.

UHPlus · #**172** 3rd January 2008, 01:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by truehappiness

demand perfection.

? perfection?

the basic requirement if being a SINGer is to sing well...

ok... she can sing while in the recording studio and stuffs, but she can't even have the confidence to perform good live vocal in her concerts...what had she been doing all these while?

a singer who can't sing live...imo she's a pop idol / icon / fashionist and hell she's not a singer or musician...

truehappiness · #**173** 3rd January 2008, 01:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UHPlus

? perfection?

the basic requirement if being a SINGer is to sing well...

ok... she can sing while in the recording studio and stuffs, but she can't even have the confidence to perform good live vocal in her concerts...what had she been doing all these while?

a singer who can't sing live...imo she's a pop idol / icon / fashionist and hell she's not a singer or musician...

Doesn't have the confidence? Then what is she doing out there singing anyway? Jeez, choose your words correctly.

She can sing in her concerts, as proven by what HilaryDuffFanBoy saw, and I don't think anything you say can change that fact. :|

And if you read my post entirely, you'd notice that I said that fans who would leave her just because of one bad live would be demanding perfection from her. :|

UHPlus · #**174** 3rd January 2008, 02:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by truehappiness

just because of one bad live would be demanding perfection from her. :|

god bless you..i seen too much to make me disappointed in her

UHPlus · #**175** 3rd January 2008, 02:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by truehappiness

Then what is she doing out there singing anyway?

just because of one bad live would be demanding perfection from her. :|

god bless you..i seen too much to make me disappointed in her

and she's not singing...she's producing off-pitched sounds

se7entheaven · #**176** 3rd January 2008, 02:05 PM

wow
seems that there are battles here between UHPlus and truehappiness
It's ok guys
both of you are in love with different artist-namie and ayu...so let it be
I wonder If namie sounds like ayu in CDL will UHPlus still dare to 'protect' like truehappiness does? LOL admit it...nobody's perfect guys... as long as ayu sings LIVE it's ok...can u imagine if ayu is someone like britney? lol I will 'die' soon if I found out so

truehappiness · #**177** 3rd January 2008, 02:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UHPlus

god bless you..i seen too much to make me disappointed in her

and she's not singing...she's producing off-pitched sounds

Maybe to you, but then again, I have to repeat myself: You're really bad at being an Ayu fan. At least have the decency to not be an idiot about things like this. In the end, you end up looking like a foolish person anyway.

As Ayu says:

Quote:

Whether or not I may do something
I'm talked about behind my back
Let it be

se7entheaven · #**178** 3rd January 2008, 02:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UHPlus

god bless you..i seen too much to make me disappointed in her

and she's not singing...she's producing off-pitched sounds

how do u know that?
do u think ayu pretends to do so? or she wants to sing off pitched? It's not her fault dear...singers are human..ok..they are not perfect...u can't always demand her to sing like the most perfect singer in the world lol...she's not perfect and that's what makes her nice to watch...when people has an unperfection in them...they are human...not GOD lol...I think u know that.

well...ayu has tried her best...u can't expect your throat to sounds good like all the time...can u ask it to sounds good? like if you cough can u ask it to stop so u can sing well...? that's magical

UHPlus · #**179** 3rd January 2008, 02:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by se7entheaven

so let it be
I wonder If namie sounds like ayu in CDL will UHPlus still dare to 'protect' like truehappiness does?

if namie was to sound anything like ayumi...i'll F her and tell her to go take some vocal lessons ... i wouldn't be interested in her in the first place....

luckily the one and only jpop singer i know who can't sing live is ayumi..maybe ERIKA too...that's why she never sang live before on during her tv performances...

YUI also has a very shaky and untrained live vocal...but she sounded great with only acoustic guitar and not with a live band...

for ayumi, nothing beautiful comes out of her mouth that are not edited or altered with...

truehappiness · #**180** 3rd January 2008, 02:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UHPlus

if namie was to sound anything like ayumi...i'll F her and tell her to go take some vocal lessons ... i wouldn't be interested in her in the first place....

luckily the one and only jpop singer i know who can't sing live is ayumi

for ayumi, nothing beautiful comes out of her mouth that are not edited or altered with...

You, sir, are a terrible person.

I don't know if anyone in the world would want to have you as a fan. So rotten!